Teenage Dream vs Welcome to New York
Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) vs Blank Space
California Gurls vs Style
Firework vs Out of the Woods
Peacock vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
Circle the Drain vs Shake It Off
The One That Got Away vs I Wish You Would
E.T. vs Bad Blood
Who Am I Living For? vs Wildest Dreams
Pearl vs How You Get the Girl
Hummingbird Heartbeat vs This Love
Not Like the Movies vs I Know Places
Part of Me vs Clean
Wide Awake vs Wonderland
Dressin' Up vs You Are In Love
E.T. (Remix) vs New Romantics

10 - 5

No surprise. TD is one of the best albums ever

(i love katy perry, so no one give me **** for this.)

TD is the better POP album.
although 1989 is still pop, it's more consistently good and meaningful, whereas TD has a lot more shallow songs that are just for fun. a lot of the songs on 1989 are written very well.

TD is more fun, but 1989 is more meaningful to me, and seems more artistic.

Ok let's try this.
*means I hate both songs so random choice.

Teenage Dream vs Welcome to New York
Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) vs Blank Space
California Gurls vs Style
Firework vs Out of the Woods
Peacock vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
Circle the Drain vs Shake It Off*
The One That Got Away vs I Wish You Would*
E.T. vs Bad Blood
Who Am I Living For? vs Wildest Dreams
Pearl vs How You Get the Girl*
Hummingbird Heartbeat vs This Love*
Not Like the Movies vs I Know Places
Part of Me vs Clean*
Wide Awake vs Wonderland
Dressin' Up vs You Are In Love
E.T. (Remix) vs New Romantics

TD:5
1989:11

Let me add that if TD was sung by someone else It probably would've won. It's a better pop album overral than 1989.

Teenage Dream vs Welcome to New York
Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) vs Blank Space
California Gurls vs Style
Firework vs Out of the Woods
Peacock vs All You Had to Do Was Stay
Circle the Drain vs Shake It Off
The One That Got Away vs I Wish You Would
E.T. vs Bad Blood
Pearl vs How You Get the Girl
Part of Me vs Clean
Wide Awake vs Wonderland
E.T. (Remix) vs New Romantics

I removed a few pairs with songs I've never heard 'cause I've never listened to TD in full.
4 : 8
1989