Haley and Pia are the only acceptable choices.

Please, everyone knows that's Haley Reinhart.

This Time was a bop
She should've released her debut album a long time ago
Luckily J.Lo still cares and supports her

um ... Lauren??
Pia, Haley, Kendra Chantelle, Rachel Zevita, even Karen Rodriguez come before LAUREN

Anyway tho

I love her voice in this despite the chord progression being soooo generic lawd
They sound gorgeous so I use

Mess I thought this would be a messy quote

Lauren's audition carried her to Top 2. She peaked then and never sounded as good again.

Jacob

Pia >>>>>>>>

Haley's the true queen of AI10

nnnn not you guys having a 3 year old idol stan war

Just goes to show the IMPACT she made with her heavenly vocals on I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing. Lauren peaking months before Haley and Pia and still outlasting them. IMPACT I said.

i'm pretty sure all 3 of those girls had better voices than lauren

Jacob?

Lusky Stank >>>

mess

That's not impact. That's just America voting for nothing but country acts. Keep in mind it was an entire country finale because of Lauren & Scotty

let's take some time to admire the flawless Pia

Pia is hot, but I prefer Haley's voice.

This has to be a troll post.

I love Haley, but Pia can absolutely SING too! This is beautiful.