Both lead singles by pop girls - check
Both sound like other songs - check
Both terrible and overrated- check
Both Max Martin songs -check
Both #1s and replaced by new artists - check


Conclusion: YES.

And so did SIO

what on earth SIO is overrated

Unlike Fearless, Red peaked at top 5 in basically every country it charted, and Red's singles were far more succesful than Fearless singles.

HY isn't even in 4/4 time though

Let that question sink in

Both have competitor from viral video hits (you know who!)

No.

Not even close Swifties.

There are a lot of coincidence if you think so, so yes.

Both overrated imo although Roar has grown on me

Roar is about to reach 6M in the US, 1M in the UK etc