Depends on how you look at it. I love all girls, but PCD was a brand and Nicole was the voice and to some extend the face. I doubt a reunion with the other 5 would do much, since it was the total package, with Nicole as lead that sold. I bet that if they would let Nicole perform with two blondes, a red head and an afro american girl (with some random adlibs), not much people from the GP would notice that something changed.

The GP would notice, ekhm the GP actually noticed when Nicole performed with some other girls after Kim, Ash, Mel & Jess had left:



Yeah, I remember gossip portals and music sites reporting that and people didn't like it.

Well I think that we shouldn't take the failure of the impossible reunion without Nicole for granted. Fate is unpredictable. Nicole has been always far from being my fave, but after they split, I truly thought that even if she hadn't make it in the USA, she would have been really successful worldwide. I gave her a lot of credit in that matter. I must admit that the whole PCD situation has been always a paradox for me. "No Nicole, No PCD; No PCD, No Nicole".

The reunion without Nicole is not going to happen ofc. But I still want that, not only to hear how PCD really sounds like (Supernatural demo ) but also out of curiosity. To see if PCD is really nothing without Nicole.

OMG such an essay

All of the girls have put out solo work (whether songs/EPs/albums) I think they'd have to be pretty desperate and broke to go back to being back-up dancers lipsynching to "lalala" and "aha"

Why do people want a reunion without Nicole? She was the voice of PCD, without her there's no identity and it wouldn't sound like PCD. She's the key element to the group.

I'm getting a wp for telling the truth

People want a reunion without Nicole who is the voice of PCD

I'm out

omg stop

i have heard derriere, woman up and their other solo singles

they are so bad and cannot sing

only jessica is ok

Ohhh, so the other dolls sang THAT part! I always wondered who did the "HA HA HA HA" part.

Nicole forming back in with the PCD would do a lot.

People are not here for solo Nicole. But if it's Nicole ft. 5 other girls, people are here for it, despite her still singing 99% of the vocals.

serving kris jenner

So much shade in this thread

You didn't read what you bolded in my reply obviously. Do the girls you posted included two blondes, a red head etc, ? and you post gossip portals and music sites, those are not the GP, the GP are mainly people who don't know any stuff, they just like their music and sassy videos.

I get what you mean though, but we know what PCD really sounds like because the album 'PCD' actually had Carmit and Melody on a fair share of songs. It was just because of Nicole pressured back to PCD and Carmit leaving that Doll Domination ended up like a Nicole solo album with additional vocals by Melody. The album "PCD" is basically what PCD is and was meant to be.

Ehh... Gossip portals are something that the GP reads, also most stories from gossip portals are later put in tabloids and those are definitely read by the GP.

The picture I posted is nothing but a lil photo from Antin's twitter from a private performance, yet people noticed that something changed and made news out of it. People also noticed that it includes Melody & Ashley look-a-likes and a Kimberly wannabe. Jessica also had brown hair for a short time while she was in PCD. When Carmit left, people have also noticed that despite Jessica dyeing her her red.

And no we don't know how PCD really sounds like since I don't remember them singing all together.

exactly

its basicly Nicole surrounded by some background dancers

Because that is not what PCD is, PCD is based on Burlesque troupes which have one to three singers (with mainly one being the leadsinger) and the rest of the group is eye candy. So yeah the real PCD has already been shown during the PCD era since Melody, Nicole and Carmit have done multiply songs together.
I get that you mean harmonizing, shared vocals etc. But that would not be "PCD', that would be any regular girlgroup.

But I geuss we both have our opinions, so let's agree to disagree

He's trying to say that the people who comment on pop culture and gossip sites are not representative of normal, average people. The vast majority of the world have no idea about the 4 replacement dancers after Melody, Ashley, Jessica and Kimberly quit. Also, most non-fans didn't notice when Carmit left either. I had to explain to people that Jessica was not the redhead when "When I Grow Up" came out.

Exactly.