Hmm... Yeah, I'll keep myself grounded before I get too excited. If anything's really exciting it's nice to see that' she's still eligible to get very high scores up in the 80's if she actually gets 100's. I doubt she will, but it'd be nice to see.

It doesn't matter if it gets a negative review or a few. Obviously not everyone is a professional and not everyone can put their personal feelings aside (although as critics they should be required to). This is going to get mixed reviews (hopefully more on the positive side) but it's not a downhill spiral as the person I replied to suggested. That's all, it wasn't an attempt to “drag“ or “expose“ them.

Hmm... Ok.

It looks like it's going to be positive, rather than mixed.

Yay, I wonder what score they will decide for the Chicago Tribune

Hopefully 90-100. There were no unsatisfactory words in it.

The Chicago Tribune is usually ruthless. :shocked:

Possibly. I'm not sure about 100, but 80 or 90 seems likely.

I'd go with 88 for Chicago Tribune.

If Gaga does get a Grammy slot, I really hope she just does Lush Life solo.

It won't be an odd number like that, it will be either 80, 85, 90, 95, or 100.

Nah, for some reason MC has assigned a lot of their reviews 88. Go check their page. It must be some computer algorithm thing.

Critics with personal feelings should be excluded by metacritic tbh Metacritic should not allow reviews like a few of Tiny Mix Tapes and this Slant one to appear on their page. It only discredits them.

I'm so happy this is looking good.

I'm so happy this is looking good.

Chicago Tribune rates out of 4 stars, 3.5/4 stars is an 88.

I'd say a 60-70

More likely 90... They said Goody Goody was the loss of the album. Mess.

Ahh that makes sense then! I think 3.5/4 is definitely what it'll be getting then.