Not Bey and Rih.

Rihanna has an R&B/Urban base. She can switch it up and still be successful in the urban whelm. Pop is not the only genre people. I am not a huge Rihanna fan but i know her versatility will keep her relevant for years to come. Now if she flops in the urban whelm, then she's done.

Mostly agreed . Why would that girl be talking about pop radio playing her when she's proven to be queen of multiformat?

Rih. After she loses her looks her songwriting team will go on to the next fresh faced chateneuse.

Same thing with Katy but only cuz her tunes are generic.

Gaga and Katy

She'll still receive less songs. Let's be real: people send her songs due to pop radio playing her, and she'll be closer to 30.

I don't think any of the girls listed will be done by the end of the decade like clockwork, but the girls that actually have some creative involvement in the music making process (all of them except for Rihanna) will find it less difficult to put out music.

What proof do you have that this is true a part from your own biases. Have you looked at the writing credits for her albums? what logic is this?

I think ATRL is too harsh on Gaga. Not my favorite artist, fan base not too fond of them, but you can't deny she has talent.

There are two things that will keep you relevant, talent and appeal. At Gaga's peak, she had both, but now her talent remains. If I am not mistaken, her fans are about her talent. If not, we wouldn't see a Gaga stan in every thread.

Katy Perry fan base is a bunch of delusional people who gets off on her success. That is it. I want to see her fans remain loyal during a flop era. Britney fans proved themselves. The BeyHive proved themselves, now the monsters are proving themselves.

I just LOVE how you know all of us.

---
Gaga

Gaga ofc

I honestly believe Taylor. I don't see people caring very much in 10 years if this is all she has to offer.
Gaga can turn it around with the general public if she wishes, she can go any which way. And it's all up to her. Whether she decides to stay artsy, or go more pop is entirely up to her. Her diversity will keep her around.

This comment has no substance.

Substance: refute my claim

Can't wait to see the people voting for Gaga to take back their words. None of them will be gone.

Not when Roar and Dark Horse are her BIGGEST hits ever + PRISM is one of the best sellers this year. Funny how you forgot to say GAGA, but I know why: you do know she's already there.

I kinda agree. Taylor/Beyoncé have that drive/determination that the other girls just don't have.

First of all, it's apart not a part. Secondly, the rate at which she puts out albums indicates that she in fact does not spend much time writing, producing, and composing herself. Every other girl doesn't put out yearly albums, because having creative involvement that goes beyond paying to be an executive producer takes time and effort. Didn't Sia openly state she was shocked that Rihanna sang "Diamonds" the exact way Sia did on the demo she sent to the label?