Poll: Xtina vs Beyonce: Bigger hitmaker in the 10s? - Page 3

Saintlor

Quote:

Originally posted by Haribo

They are?

U.S. iTunes:

639. Christina Aguilera – Fighter
1268. Christina Aguilera – Genie In a Bottle

259. Beyoncé – Crazy In Love
449. Beyoncé – Love On Top
559. Beyoncé – Run the World (Girls)
566. Beyoncé – Halo
738. Beyoncé – Single Ladies (Put a Ring On It)
769. Beyoncé – If I Were a Boy
1124. Beyoncé – Irreplaceable

Not to people who buy music at least.

YouTube

Beyoncé – old songs above 50 million views:

Single Ladies: 317 million
Halo: 226 million
If I Were a Boy: 143 million
Crazy in Love: 120 million
Beautiful Liar: 99 million
Irreplaceable: 99 million
Sweet Dreams: 87 million
Diva: 80 million
Video Phone: 58 million

Xtina – old songs above 50 million views:

Lady Marmalade: 101 million
Candyman: 80 million
Hurt: 76 million
Beautiful: 52 million

Spotify

Beyoncé – old songs above 10 million streams:

Halo: 68 million
Single Ladies: 40 million
If I Were a Boy: 38 million
Sweet Dreams: 34 million
Crazy in Love: 30 million
Irreplaceable: 23 million
Broken-Hearted Girl: 20 million
Baby Boy: 16 million
'03 Bonnie & Clyde: 13 million
Listen: 12 million
Diva: 12 million
Beautiful Liar: 12 million
Ave Maria: 12 million
Ego: 11 million
I Miss You: 11 million
Lift Off: 10 million
Part II (On the Run): 10 million
Naughty Girl: 10 million
Dance for You: 10 million
Smash into You: 10 million

Xtina – old songs above 10 million streams:

Beautiful: 15 million
Lady Marmalade: 13 million
Hurt: 13 million
Fighter: 12 million
Genie in a Bottle: 11 million

Beyonce's older songs are higher on iTunes because Beyonce is slaying right now, not because they are more remembered. Same with VEVO.

Also don't compare VEVO views because they're a mess with uploading. They've uploaded, deleted and reuploaded countless old Britney songs which have resulted in her losing loads of views -- I imagine this might've happened with other artists.

***Chu

unbothered

Xtina in the 00s

Bey in the 10s

Donquizote

Xtina obviously

Haribo

Quote:

Originally posted by Saintlor

Beyonce's older songs are higher on iTunes because Beyonce is slaying right now, not because they are more remembered. Same with VEVO.

Also don't compare VEVO views because they're a mess with uploading. They've uploaded, deleted and reuploaded countless old Britney songs which have resulted in her losing loads of views -- I imagine this might've happened with other artists.

Beyoncé's songs are always higher. Her catalog sales are way bigger than Christina's.

Same with Bey's videos actually, but still, they have more views.

Desert Rain

Quote:

Originally posted by Haribo

They are?

U.S. iTunes:

639. Christina Aguilera – Fighter
1268. Christina Aguilera – Genie In a Bottle

259. Beyoncé – Crazy In Love
449. Beyoncé – Love On Top
559. Beyoncé – Run the World (Girls)
566. Beyoncé – Halo
738. Beyoncé – Single Ladies (Put a Ring On It)
769. Beyoncé – If I Were a Boy
1124. Beyoncé – Irreplaceable

And not to people who buy music at least.

YouTube

Beyoncé – old songs above 50 million views:

Single Ladies: 317 million
Halo: 226 million
If I Were a Boy: 143 million
Crazy in Love: 120 million
Beautiful Liar: 99 million
Irreplaceable: 99 million
Sweet Dreams: 87 million
Diva: 80 million
Video Phone: 58 million

Xtina – old songs above 50 million views:

Lady Marmalade: 101 million
Candyman: 80 million
Hurt: 76 million
Beautiful: 52 million

Not to people who watch videos too.

Spotify

Beyoncé – old songs above 10 million streams:

Halo: 68 million
Single Ladies: 40 million
If I Were a Boy: 38 million
Sweet Dreams: 34 million
Crazy in Love: 30 million
Irreplaceable: 23 million
Broken-Hearted Girl: 20 million
Baby Boy: 16 million
'03 Bonnie & Clyde: 13 million
Listen: 12 million
Diva: 12 million
Beautiful Liar: 12 million
Ave Maria: 12 million
Ego: 11 million
I Miss You: 11 million
Lift Off: 10 million
Part II (On the Run): 10 million
Naughty Girl: 10 million
Dance for You: 10 million
Smash into You: 10 million

Xtina – old songs above 10 million streams:

Beautiful: 15 million
Lady Marmalade: 13 million
Hurt: 13 million
Fighter: 12 million
Genie in a Bottle: 11 million

And also not to people who stream songs.

The receipts!!!

Lucyyyyyyyyy

Quote:

Originally posted by Haribo

They are?

U.S. iTunes:

639. Christina Aguilera – Fighter
1268. Christina Aguilera – Genie In a Bottle

259. Beyoncé – Crazy In Love
449. Beyoncé – Love On Top
559. Beyoncé – Run the World (Girls)
566. Beyoncé – Halo
738. Beyoncé – Single Ladies (Put a Ring On It)
769. Beyoncé – If I Were a Boy
1124. Beyoncé – Irreplaceable

And not to people who buy music at least.

YouTube

Beyoncé – old songs above 50 million views:

Single Ladies: 317 million
Halo: 226 million
If I Were a Boy: 143 million
Crazy in Love: 120 million
Beautiful Liar: 99 million
Irreplaceable: 99 million
Sweet Dreams: 87 million
Diva: 80 million
Video Phone: 58 million

Xtina – old songs above 50 million views:

Lady Marmalade: 101 million
Candyman: 80 million
Hurt: 76 million
Beautiful: 52 million

Not to people who watch videos too.

Spotify

Beyoncé – old songs above 10 million streams:

Halo: 68 million
Single Ladies: 40 million
If I Were a Boy: 38 million
Sweet Dreams: 34 million
Crazy in Love: 30 million
Irreplaceable: 23 million
Broken-Hearted Girl: 20 million
Baby Boy: 16 million
'03 Bonnie & Clyde: 13 million
Listen: 12 million
Diva: 12 million
Beautiful Liar: 12 million
Ave Maria: 12 million
Ego: 11 million
I Miss You: 11 million
Lift Off: 10 million
Part II (On the Run): 10 million
Naughty Girl: 10 million
Dance for You: 10 million
Smash into You: 10 million

Xtina – old songs above 10 million streams:

Beautiful: 15 million
Lady Marmalade: 13 million
Hurt: 13 million
Fighter: 12 million
Genie in a Bottle: 11 million

And also not to people who stream songs.

Of course more people will be buying and streaming Beyonce's music right now. She's the center of attention ATM and is more relevant than Xtina. Doesn't change the fact that Xtina's hits will be more remembered in the long run and were bigger WW

Haribo

Quote:

Originally posted by Lucyyyyyyyyy

Of course more people will be buying and streaming Beyonce's music right now. She's the center of attention ATM and is more relevant than Xtina. Doesn't change the fact that Xtina's hits will be more remembered in the long run and were bigger WW

What world are you living in? And

@ the WW part.

TrieLz

In term of single wise:

00s I think they both tied, xtina slaying in early-mid 00s (stripped-BTB era) while bey slaying in the late 00s IASF era + DIL era)

In 10s Xtina, if we count for feature.
If only for solo hits, then Bey.

Lucyyyyyyyyy

Quote:

Originally posted by Haribo

What world are you living in? And

@ the WW part.

Let me not.

°ColdFire°

Not Haribo reports my post. PRESSED

Anyway, Xtina in 00's. Bey in 10's.

B'Day

Quote:

Originally posted by alfonso12

Beyoncé.

I mean, she has Crazy In Love, Baby Boy, Check On It, Irreplaceable, Beautiful Liar, Single Ladies, If I Were a Boy, Halo, Sweet Dreams, and Drunk In Love. Christina has Beautiful and maybe Ain't no other man.

/endthread

B'Day

Quote:

Originally posted by Lucyyyyyyyyy

Of course more people will be buying and streaming Beyonce's music right now. She's the center of attention ATM and is more relevant than Xtina. Doesn't change the fact that Xtina's hits will be more remembered in the long run and were bigger WW

6_INCH_HEELS

Beyonce. The facts simply don't lie.

slw84

Quote:

Originally posted by D.M.F

Xtina's biggest hits according to Billboard -

01. Moves Like Jagger
05. Say Something

- http://m.billboard.com/entry/view/id/97773

Say Something's another song bigger than every song in Bey's discography. It went #1 in more countries than Crazy In Love!

Isn't that somewhat self-shade though

slw84

Quote:

Originally posted by Eternium

Christina thanks to her hit features. Bey walks away with tour gross, album sales, impact, etc. so it's not like it's a big deal to give Christina her props where it's due.
Only because Billboard used a formula that relies heavily on radioplay, which is a crock of **** when Beyonce paid for four of her biggest radio hits (CiL, Baby Boy, Me Myself and I and Naughty Girl). Bey sold less than 10M albums in that span, too

Actually it was also due to certifications for which come artists have over 30M uncertified singles and albums. Don't blame Bey...blame the label. Some artists labels get them certs on point because she was the most certified artist beating eminem who clearly outperformed her.

*-ChriZ-*

I think both have hits that will be remembered for a LONG time in history in the 00s:

X has Genie in a Bottle, Dirrty, Beautiful.
Beyonce has Crazy in Love, Halo, Single Ladies, Listen (due to Casting Shows).

When it comes to the 10s, Bey is clearly ahead.