I think both are ridiculous. To be honest, I will slam anyone. I have no shame when it comes to this. I am skinny af, but I will still people out on being skinny. I call myself a Holocaust Survivor because I am very skinny. I am confident in myself to not let people's words affect me.
Anyways, yeah. It's wrong. We should all be better to each other. Skinny shaming barely happens though. Except people say that I am sick looking because I am too skinny. Honestly though? If you ARE going to judge someone about something then weight would be the thing that you could do it on. People can't choose their sexuality. They can't choose their skin color. Yet, they CAN choose their lifestyle. If you're skinny, eat more and exercise. If you're fat, eat less and eat healthier. Sure, some people might have some medical condition, but not every person has some self-diagnosed problem that makes them immune from gaining/losing weight.
It's better to keep your mouth to yourself when it comes to judging people though. (This whole comment was a mess. I'm tired. I'm sorry.

)