Poll: Will Beyoncé Ever Have A Song Bigger Than SL? - Page 2

OnlyXtina

In europe Crazy In Love, Beautiful Liar, If I Were A Boy and Halo were bigger.

Superpower

Halo is bigger.

aaronsmithjune1

No...

But I think she could easily have 2 or 3 more IIWAB sized hits...

And how can someone disagree with that single ladies breakdown???even if it didn't sell 10m.I'm 100% positive 9 million of it's true..but atrl love to discredit Beyonce..

Eternium

Quote:

Originally posted by Haribo

Nope. And you need to stop being pressed over the Korean market even though we all know why you are.

I stan So Nyeo Shi Dae and HyunA and am a huge fan of T-ARA (specifically Jiyeon's eyes), BoA, SISTAR, Ailee, IU, etc.

Think about this: 3 years ago in the exact same time frame, only one song in the top 40 sold less than 100k in South Korea and the top track sold over 450k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

In 2014, 30 songs in the top 40 sold less than 100k and the top track sold 255k, which would've been enough for a #7 placement in 2011.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2014, the top foreign song sold 40k and only the top 6 songs sold over 10k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2011, the top foreign song sold 66k and the top 21 songs sold over 10k, and that was a weak week for 2011 (MLJ had already ruled for multiple weeks).
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

Tell me where my lies were

Simplyvirtue

Quote:

Originally posted by Eternium

I stan So Nyeo Shi Dae and HyunA and am a huge fan of T-ARA (specifically Jiyeon's eyes), BoA, SISTAR, Ailee, IU, etc.

Think about this: 3 years ago in the exact same time frame, only one song in the top 40 sold less than 100k in South Korea and the top track sold over 450k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

In 2014, 30 songs in the top 40 sold less than 100k and the top track sold 255k, which would've been enough for a #7 placement in 2011.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2014, the top foreign song sold 40k and only the top 6 songs sold over 10k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2011, the top foreign song sold 66k and the top 21 songs sold over 10k, and that was a weak week for 2011 (MLJ had already ruled for multiple weeks).
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

Tell me where my lies were

lets go play in the stand your ground thread

Simplyvirtue

and to answer the question YES its really not that hard she just needs a generic song to sell that amount in the 21st century

TheVoiceXtina

Quote:

Originally posted by Simplyvirtue

and to answer the question YES its really not that hard she just needs a generic song to sell that amount in the 21st century

so what went wrong with XO then?

MovinKindaSlow

Quote:

Originally posted by Eternium

I stan So Nyeo Shi Dae and HyunA and am a huge fan of T-ARA (specifically Jiyeon's eyes), BoA, SISTAR, Ailee, IU, etc.

Think about this: 3 years ago in the exact same time frame, only one song in the top 40 sold less than 100k in South Korea and the top track sold over 450k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

In 2014, 30 songs in the top 40 sold less than 100k and the top track sold 255k, which would've been enough for a #7 placement in 2011.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2014, the top foreign song sold 40k and only the top 6 songs sold over 10k.
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...14&f_type=week

In 2011, the top foreign song sold 66k and the top 21 songs sold over 10k, and that was a weak week for 2011 (MLJ had already ruled for multiple weeks).
Source: http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/chart/dow...11&f_type=week

Tell me where my lies were

Very interesting.

Simplyvirtue

Quote:

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

so what went wrong with XO then?

xo is far from generic so stop the trolling

Eternium

Quote:

Originally posted by Simplyvirtue

lets go play in the stand your ground thread

Sis, you really that scared to speak your piece here? Feel free to bring it to my wall.

Quote:

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

so what went wrong with XO then?

Released after the album, music video released too early, didn't come off the back of a successful pop song, unfavored compared to other dual-single, etc. You're right that it was generic and clearly created to be a multi-format smash, but it wasn't handled well at all

Simplyvirtue

Quote:

Originally posted by Eternium

Sis, you really that scared to speak your piece here? Feel free to bring it to my wall.

Released after the album, music video released too early, didn't come off the back of a successful pop song, unfavored compared to other dual-single, etc. You're right that it was generic and clearly created to be a multi-format smash, but it wasn't handled well at all

Sis, why would I speak my mind here or on your wall to get a WP. Thats why I said go to the stand your ground thread. Ki

Lein

Yes, when Crazy in Love exists