I'm not reading all of those reviews but Pink has always been the dark horse.
To me, if she were more attractive and was more known for dancing she'd really be the top entertainer of the recent generation.
She sings well.
She sings with depth and emotion
She writes great songs.
She is versatile (image wise, her musicality etc.)
She dances well despite not being known for it
She has had a couple of iconic performances
She reinvents herself enough to remain relevant while never being the top seller at least top 10 seller.
Who else could pull off r&b, punk pop, pop rock and hot AC?
I do want her to reivent herself a lot more for her next album.
I feel like her last two or three eras showed minimal growth.
I want the next era to be more provocative.
Also, I think she should be the next video vanguard and should get those lifetime achievement awards from AMAs and thinks of that nature.