Quote:
Originally posted by MattyTacos
1. Both have 4 octaves, same range
2. She may have more power, but there can be TOO much of a good thing. I don't need to be screamed at for it to be a good voice
3. You can understand what Ariana is saying...
4. Have you actually seen any performances of Ariana's emotional performances to prove that?
|
1. The actual octaves they have are different
And again, receipts.
2. You insisted Ariana had equal power. Point stands. IGNORING that:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxeHfB-udlI - Where's the screaming? Anyways, no. More power is always a good thing. If Xtina actually did OVERSINGING, that would be a flaw in her technique. Therefore, her vocals are still objectively superior to Ariana's.
3. ATRL disagrees. That's one of the most common criticisms against her.
4. Yes, I have seen several live performances of hers. Lacking. Not only that, but you can hear
She still has 4, and Xtina has 4. As for Proof:
i say they are even.