I noticed someone with a certain avi said something was good, and I immediately assumed the person was lying; Because of their avi, I assumed they had poor taste.

Do you judge someone based off their avi?

Yes.

Judging you.

you will be judged or you will be ignored

That's a good thing, don't be sad.

Not really.

No. If I look slightly to the right, I can judge them for what they are saying.

I try not to judge users negatively by their avatars.

No. Posts who attack someone's avi or sig is very cringeworthy and embarrassing.

"But you have ____ in your sig"
"But you have ____ in your avi"

Sometimes. Some avis are just too tragic not to be noticed.

Nope.

Yes, everyone does. It is the "first impression" of the poster.

I know not to, but understand avatars can influence a tone to posts most of the time.

Only if it's a squished avi, then I judge them for not being able to crop or resize it correctly.

No