???? They sold literally the exact same amount ww

TEOM

And it aint close.

Song of the decade..
6 Million + Sold in the US
Its like that, dont forget about us, shake it off smashing the charts
3(?) Grammies

Circus doesnt come close. sorry.

TEOM, Circus and Love? are the only comebacks in the list:

Katy didnt even start, so she was coming back from where exactly?
4 wasnt even a flop so why would she need to comeback?
And Christina? She had the hit and went into hiding right after, so i wouldnt call it a comeback!
And Madonna never really left either

EDIT: And Britney never left either, but it was a huge PR comeback

Madonna didn't really go nowhere also aside from US labeling her a flop before Confessions.

Mariah on the other hand had Glitter and Charmbracelet before that.

Mariah and Brit can actually call their albums a true Comeback in every possible way.

Their sales also differ by at least 1 million which isn't too much since both have sold more than 10 million globally. Mariahs comeback is also more iconic because of the drama sorrounding it.
That's why Brit comes a close second.

It still outsold it. Not by much, it outsold Mariah's album by 300k-600k. Anyways simply put, Madonna sold more singles, had a bigger album, a bigger tour. To put things in perspective the "song of the decade" we belong togeteher has sold the same amount as Hung Up in the US even after the countless performances and the huge radio support. We won't even bring up WW receipts because hung up sold almost 3x as much as the "song ofthe decade" WBT

when will others? im so proud of ha

Madonna sold more WW and her Confessions tour grossed over 3x more than Mariah's.

We Belong Together was the 'song of the decade' locally. Hung Up was a record-breaking global #1.

Beyoncé and Britney have nothing to do here 4 & Blackout was commercially successful.

American Life was undoubtedly a underperformance everywhere. The question being asked is "who had the biggest comeback" so yes is still Madonna's.

Circus or Emancipation tbh
also Ray Of Light should of been added by Madonna

Ask Billboard, MTV, Rolling Stones, who had the biggest comeback. 200k difference in album sales doesn't equate to a bigger comeback.
Mariah had the title of the Comeback queen by literally any publications worldwide.

Hers was truly bigger by critics, fans and the GPs eyes. Madonnas comeback era was Ray of Light not Confessions.

COADF because it is more difficult for a female singer who is in her mid 40s to have a huge comeback than someone who is still in their 30s ….
I wonder if Mariah can have a comeback at the age of 47 like Madonna did….

According to Mediatraffic the difference is 200k, hardly any difference at all especially in 2005. WBT has sold 1.7 million in the US and Hung Up is at 1.2 million so not quite Which is even more impressive considering 6 million people in the US own TEOM compared to the 1.7 million who own COADF. Also I'm pretty sure that 9 million is not 3x as much as 5 million but ok sweetie

Mariah, followed by Britney.

teom slaying the poll

The Emancipation of Mimi
No one expected ha to slay again.

The Emancipation of Mimi by far.