Discussion: Is Taylor Swift the most talented among young pop stars? - Page 7

IamCY

Yes. The only young girl with anything over her is Ariana her vocals,

Vespertine

Quote:

Originally posted by Swim

Ariana's debut was critically acclaimed (81 on Metacritic), so no point in bringing up the critics.

It's interesting how intimidated some of y'all are by Ariana's talent. Seethe.

And I said Taylor is the one girl to get consistent good reviews. Call me when Ariana's new album comes out and lands in the 60s (if Problem is anything to judge by).

And it's funny that you think critical acclaim (based on 9 reviews, and mostly from fluff publications like EW lol) matters when she had next to NO input into the creation of her own album. THAT does not constitute musical talent, no sir!

But yes, I'm the one seething when you had to resort to lies and flamebait about Taylor's music!

KekeStann

Quote:

Originally posted by Vespertine

And I said Taylor is the one girl to get consistent good reviews. Call me when Ariana's new album comes out and lands in the 60s (if Problem is anything to judge by).

And it's funny that you think critical acclaim (based on 9 reviews, and mostly from fluff publications like EW lol) matters when she had next to NO input into the creation of her own album. THAT does not constitute musical talent, no sir!

But yes, I'm the one seething when you had to resort to lies and flamebait about Taylor's music!

I'm gonna bookmark this just for when MY Everything drops. Sis Ariana has got you seriously pressed.

like2throw

did someone really compare Becky G to Taylor Swift in this thread?

Giselle

Miley. Then her.

shadesofwrong

These Araiana stans are an hopeless case. Who is this girl? Until 1 year ago you hated her since she was starring on a Nickeleodon show and now that she tries to be a pop-star you love her? For what? Singing well, but without any emotions, convinction, charisma and anything? Let's not make her the new Whitney Houston, Ariana is just a girl who sings well, stop.. You can find millions of girl like this out there, there are better girls than here on the talent shows..
And you drag someone like Taylor who WRITES, CO-PRODUCES, PLAYS, has CHARISMA can be both the GIRL WITH THE GUITAR and PERFORMER, organizes her tours, she has 100000% control on her career? What do you want, exactly? It's not just about vocals, Taylor may have the best voice in the world, but she gives emotions because she sings every word meaning them, and that's better than high notes there and here.
Have more respect for Taylor Swift, a real musician and artist.

13-Fifteen-22_TS

Without a doubt, she is.

Mezter

Nope. But she is talented. Her songwriting is beyond overrated on ATRL though

Quote:

Originally posted by Artemisia

The Ariana stans are mighty cocky aren't they

I should make a thread about it.

So this is why you made the thread (that backfired)

Zaynsus

Safe&Sound

Of course.
Even compared to major pop girls

Mezter

Quote:

Originally posted by like2throw

did someone really compare Becky G to Taylor Swift in this thread?

Y'all need to stop discrediting Becky. The only place she's a joke is on ATRL. She's a good rapper and good singer (decent dancer too), which takes skill. You guys need to get off your high horse

!Blue!

NO.
I'd put Lorde over her

Safe&Sound

22's choreography on BBMA >>> Ariana's dance on Problem

at least no one laughed at her

and her vocal improved a lot at RED era, she's seldom out of tune and her belt is not that flat anymore

Timber

Gotta admit, the girl is a genius melody writer. Yes.