Poll: Beyonce vs Rihanna: Greatest Hits? - Page 3

Nathan's Nicely

Quote:

Originally posted by evyonce

Ok but anyways before this turned into a who has more #1s thread, Bey would be more perfered and it would be bigger IMO. Rihanna's songs are either forgotten or outdated IMO regardless of the higher peaks on the BB Hot 100. Beyoncé has numerous signature songs and numerous of songs with much impact. Just because the song didn't peak on a favorable chart doesn't mean the song wasn't a hit, so please stop with that logic.

Howie

Quote:

Originally posted by RihannasVeryOwn

Cold hard facts or no!
And the reason why Rihanna's pre 2011 hits aren't as remembered as her post 2011 is because she continued to have hits

If she started flopping after Loud then obv the pre 2011 singles would be well known use your logic

But if they are more ICONIC than Beyonce's as you implying then they should be used with or without new hits.

Plenty of people have had NUMEROUS hits in their lifetimes but their bIGGEST hits still get MAJOR play YEARS later.

What single After Single Ladies of Rihanna's has had the impact that it had? And im not talking SALES (although none have outsold it) I'm not talking chart peak I'm talking IMPACT. We Found Love and Diamonds are two of Rihanna's biggest hits of her career, and neither had the impact outside of Sales that CIL, Irreplaceable, SL had/have.

Howie

Quote:

Originally posted by evyonce

Ok but anyways before this turned into a who has more #1s thread, Bey would be more perfered and it would be bigger IMO. Rihanna's songs are either forgotten or outdated IMO regardless of the higher peaks on the BB Hot 100. Beyoncé has numerous signature songs and numerous of songs with much impact. Just because the song didn't peak on a favorable chart doesn't mean the song wasn't a hit, so please stop with that logic.

RomanNavy

Quote:

Originally posted by evyonce

Ok but anyways before this turned into a who has more #1s thread, Bey would be more perfered and it would be bigger IMO. Rihanna's songs are either forgotten or outdated IMO regardless of the higher peaks on the BB Hot 100. Beyoncé has numerous signature songs and numerous of songs with much impact. Just because the song didn't peak on a favorable chart doesn't mean the song wasn't a hit, so please stop with that logic.

The essays to justify Beyonce losing the poll to Rihanna

Vintage Slaydrian

countless Memorable songs vs #1 Songs
Guaranteed SOLID seller vs ....CH....nvm...I've made my choice. *tips out of the room*

M A R C

Rihanna

Αnt

Bey's would sell better.

I would prefer Rihanna's though.

HumanitySector

Quote:

Originally posted by smthcrmnl

Rihanna has more #1's but Bey has ACTUAL classics and bigger hits. We all know Bey's GH would sell more too. Let's not play stupid here... If Rihanna were to release a GH, people would just cherry pick the new songs off iTunes (If it were an option) and discard the rest. Katy Perry is another one with a lot of #1's but no classics.

Name me three Beyonce's hits that were bigger than Umbrella, WFL, Diamonds, Love the Way You Lie, heck even WMN, Stay, OG? And i mean worldwide

DuaneT

Pon De Replay
S.O.S
Unfaithful
Umbrella
Hate That I Love You
Don't Stop The Music
Take A Bow
Disturbia
Russian Roulette
Rude Boy
Love The Way You Lie
Only Girl
What's My Name
S+M
We Found Love
Where Have You Been
Diamonds
Stay

Or

Crazy In Love
Irreplaceable
Halo
Single Ladies
Drunk In Love

conatus

rih has the most, but bey's are bigger.

posh

Rihanna obviously has more hits, but Bey's are far greater quality and more memorable.
One would be a #1s compilation and the other an immaculate collection.

DvnR

Some of y'all ruin every potentially good conversation with your obsessive stanning, like damn.

Chemist

Both would slay

But Rihanna's GH would compile the hits that define this generation (like The Immacullate Collection was for the dinosaur era generation)

idkher

This myth that all of Beyonce's hits are huge pop culture staples with massive impact

The fact is Beyonce has never even had a HUGE song worldwide so by default they couldn't have as much impact as Rihanna's biggest hits which have been heard by millions on every continent

It's telling that Rihanna would barely be able to fit all her top 20 hits into a two-disc GH and Beyonce's one-disc GH would probably include several songs that didn't even go top 30

G Falconer

Obviously Rih

With all that hits on her catalog.

Horus

Quote:

Originally posted by idkher

This myth that all of Beyonce's hits are huge pop culture staples with massive impact

The fact is Beyonce has never even had a HUGE song worldwide so by default they couldn't have as much impact as Rihanna's biggest hits which have been heard by millions on every continent

It's telling that Rihanna would barely be able to fit all her top 20 hits into a two-disc GH and Beyonce's one-disc GH would probably include several songs that didn't even go top 30

ikr???

But oh well, after all it's the beyhive. They have to go with all these mythical essays to make themselves believe what they want to believe!!!

The poll has spoken!!!

cancer

Rihanna has SO many MONSTER hits! I mean Umbrella, We Found Love, Only Girl (In the World) are huge huge HUGE pop songs.

Lein

How Bey's hits bigger? Especially WW. Riri wins
Single Ladies
Brazil Billboard Hot 100[217] 1
US Billboard Hot 100[81]

Crazy in Love
Ireland (IRMA)[164] 1
UK Singles (Official Charts Company)[166] 1
US Billboard Hot 100[167] 1

Quote:

Originally posted by idkher

This myth that all of Beyonce's hits are huge pop culture staples with massive impact

The fact is Beyonce has never even had a HUGE song worldwide so by default they couldn't have as much impact as Rihanna's biggest hits which have been heard by millions on every continent

It's telling that Rihanna would barely be able to fit all her top 20 hits into a two-disc GH and Beyonce's one-disc GH would probably include several songs that didn't even go top 30

This.

mandym

Rihanna

lonnie

Quote:

Originally posted by idkher

This myth that all of Beyonce's hits are huge pop culture staples with massive impact

The fact is Beyonce has never even had a HUGE song worldwide so by default they couldn't have as much impact as Rihanna's biggest hits which have been heard by millions on every continent

It's telling that Rihanna would barely be able to fit all her top 20 hits into a two-disc GH and Beyonce's one-disc GH would probably include several songs that didn't even go top 30

It's a wrap.