I feel like Hilary and Carly have pretty similar range in voice. The way Carly sings her songs on Kiss is the way I think Hilary would sing it and I could also see Carly singing Hilary's Digniity album. Their voices just seem to be perfect for each other's music.

So if Hilary had recorded "Kiss" instead of Carly, would it have done better? Would it have been a better album as a result? Would the songs sound better IYO?

Discuss.

Brother, I think it would've slayed, on some of the tracks, I wouldn't use her voice

Good point.

Maybe if Call Me Maybe was only for Carly and the rest of the album was Hilary's?