Poll: Bigger GLOBAL debut: Dangerously In Love vs Christina A

Ariel.

Which pop girl from the late 90s/early 00s had the bigger debut on a global scale?

Christina Aguilera - 9.1 million US/13 million WW = 3.9 million internationally.
Dangerously In Love - 5 million US/9.5 million WW = 4.5 million internatonally.

Single sales and tours also count. And please don't pull inflated and unrealistic receipts. Discuss.

satellites.™

99 vs 03?

Ariel.

Quote:

Originally posted by satellites.™

99 vs 03?

Your point?

Rolland

If you're gonna use mediatraffic numbers for CA, then use them too for DIL, so only 3 million outside of the US for DIL.

Also, I'm sure Xtina and her $105 million grossing tour was bigger. Plus, the singles too.

Joke is on you.

Gabriel_Spears

Christina Aguilera by far

Madam X

Xtina, easily.

ally23

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

If you're gonna use mediatraffic numbers for CA, then use them too for DIL, so only 3 million outside of the US for DIL.

Also, I'm sure Xtina and her $105 million grossing tour was bigger. Plus, the singles too.

Joke is on you.

Accordin to media traffic DIL sold over 9 millon early last year.. / usa sales @ ~4.9m not 5

Toxicity.

Legend X.

johnsuxx

CA only sold 13M?

But Christina was more global.

Ariel.

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

If you're gonna use mediatraffic numbers for CA, then use them too for DIL, so only 3 million outside of the US for DIL.

Also, I'm sure Xtina and her $105 million grossing tour was bigger. Plus, the singles too.

Joke is on you.

Mediatraffic has DIL at 9 million, that would be 4 million outside the US. I guess the joke is on YOU.

Also, I'm sure Stripped wasn't Xtina's debut so I guess the joke is on you, again.

RomanNavy

WW = US included as well so Christina.

SelenaTheWinner

HumanitySector

Christina Aguilera by far.

22 Two's

minxie

CA definitely. I didn't know Beyonce existed until 2008.

22 Two's

Quote:

Originally posted by RomanNavy

WW = US included as well so Christina.

interesting point made by RomanNavy. Let me printscreen this for further discussions.

DG1

U can't minus the US sales from the outside the US sales and call it "global" sales. Global sales is the total. I think u mean international sales?

To answer your question, Dangerously in Love.

Madam X

Quote:

Originally posted by johnsuxx

CA only sold 13M?

But Christina was more global.

17.4 million worldwide.

slobro

Christina Aguilera
Chart (1999–2000) Peak
Australian ARIA Albums Chart #21
Austrian Albums Chart #15
Belgian Flemish Albums Chart #19
Canadian Albums Chart #1
Dutch Albums Chart #21
Finnish Albums Chart #36
French SNEP Albums Chart #44
German Albums Chart #13
New Zealand RIANZ Albums Chart #5
Norwegian Albums Chart #28
Swedish Albums Chart #60
Swiss Albums Chart #5
UK Albums (OCC) #14
US Billboard 200 #1

Dangerously In Love
Chart (2003–04) Peak
Australian Albums Chart #2
Austrian Albums Chart #3
Belgian Albums Chart (Flanders) #3
Belgian Albums Chart (Wallonia) #13
Canadian Albums Chart #1
Danish Albums Chart #5
Dutch Albums Chart #4
European Top 100 Albums #1
Finnish Albums Chart #6
French Albums Chart #14
German Albums Chart #1
Greek Albums Chart #1
Hungarian Albums Chart #18
Irish Albums Chart #1
Italian Albums Chart #16
Japanese Albums Chart #12
New Zealand Albums Chart #8
Norwegian Albums Chart #1
Polish Albums Chart #18
Portuguese Albums Chart #16
Swedish Albums Chart #11
Swiss Albums Chart #2
U.S. Billboard 200 #1
U.S. Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums #1
UK Albums Chart #1

X's debut was really local while Beyoncé was fairly global.

Ariel.

Quote:

Originally posted by Money Power Glory

17.4 million worldwide.

Not even Xtina would believe that. 8 million outside the USA with the international certifications adding up to 1.7 million?