In terms of the fact that ATRL has a bout 7,000 active members where as the world has over 7 billion people, by ratio I'm way more popular here

If i go off my active ATRL friends, I'm actively engaged with 2.857% (200 at minimum/7000) of the ATRL population.
To match that ratio in real life, I would have to know .2 billion people, therefore i'm more popular here.

As for quantity, I think its a toss up

I'm irrelevant anywhere I set foot.

But I would say real life.

Not everyone saying real life

i'm more popular on Tumblr tbh and that's not a lot

Neither.