Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
I know, that's why Bad Romance is one of the biggest videos of all time, without being expensive, same for Single Ladies. But DiL is not good. It's BASIC and generic. I mean on the beach  Why didn't Broken Hearted Girl get nominated when it's miles better than DiL and it's the same concept, with 101258129 more emotions than DiL  It's just popularity, BUT that logic also doesn't work, otherwise Roar and DH should've been nominated instead of DiL ... }
But yes it's just politics so let me stop 
|
Broken Hearted Girl is cheesy and looks worse than DIL.
DIL at least matched the theme of the song. The video feels intimate and sexual. It seems like it could be a glimpse into their night somewhere between their grinding in the club and being on the kitchen floor. I admit it's not the most interesting video but Beyonce's performance sells it and it is certainly above the frolicking cheesiness of Broken Hearted Girl.