Yes but Problem is a bigger hit than Selena and Demi have ever had and Break Free is shaping up to be pretty massive too.

Just let's see how the rest of her era goes. Then we can bring this thread back to life

Yes. The last time the thread was made (Before Problem) it was yes, and it still is

If she keeps up with the success for this era and the next, she will definitely be above them. As of now, she has yet to have a 4x platinum single like Selena

Problem is already at like 2.3 million in the US and still in the top 3, she will outsell Love You Like a Love Song and Come & Get It very comfortably.

Yes she is bigger, or at least will prove to be bigger in upcoming months/years.

----
Anyway, yes. Problem is already a bigger hit than anything Demi and Selena have ever released. And Yours Truly outsold DEMI and Stars Dance effortlessly despite having only one hit. I can see her new album debuting with over 200k and not taking 2 decades to go Gold as well.

In the US? Musically yes. Her music is more popular, but her name is less known of the three

How exactly? Yours Truly outsold their latest efforts so I wouldn't be so sure about that, they'll most likely underperform yet again while Ariana only continues to get bigger.

And Problem is more global than anything they have and will ever release so let's not.

Ariana is still at the beginning of her career so my answer is no. She just released her first album less than a year ago. Her singles are proving to be bigger but as a brand & artist.. she has quite a bit to go to reach Demi & Selena's level.

Selena Gomez is a pretty well known name. She's acted in many films, had a big TV show, has a clothing line & her own perfume on top of releasing music. Demi was always the bottom of the 3 Disney girls but she's continuing to prove herself & power as time goes on & she has a really big worldwide fanbase.

Why is this thread full of Miley stans

Right now she is.