I'm trying to figure out what island she's singing about. Let's examine the lyrics...

"Last night I dreamt of San Pedro"

San Pedro, Argentina? Or one of the many other San Pedros? Or San Pedro Island, of which there are several?

"The Spanish Lullaby"

So they speak Spanish...

"Where a girl loves a boy and a boy loves a girl"

Apparently this island has traditional values?




What are your thoughts?

It's in your heart baby .

Puerto Rico duh

Have you heard about story? The song doesn't need to be about an actual place.

Anyway, I think Madonna is referring to this.

I think it's a caye or something in Belize.

I'm like 6 hours away from it

Yeah I went to Belize when I was younger and every tourist thing was like "We're the ones in the Madonna song!"

In b4 Family Guy reference

Fat Joe knows where it is. It's mentioned in this song.

Traditional values is right if it's Belize - gay ban law

Cuba.

San Pedro Sula in Honduras. Only 60 kilometers from the Atlantic Ocean

From RS Interview 2009:

It's in Belize, which is NOWHERE near

or

or

nor

but that was almost close.

It sounds like it's San Pedro Town on Ambergris Caye in Belize!

Says so right on its Wikipedia page!