You guys are ridiculous.
-2 million sold WW
-#1 on the charts
-Made it in the Top 10 WW albums of the year
-First single sold 4 million WW and was in the Top 10 for 14 weeks
-An album track made the Top 10
-Second single sold 2.5 million WW


An underperformance for what people were expecting, but not a flop by any means. And none of this "for her standards" "compared to other pop stars" crap, just look at the numbers alone. Even when you "compare to other pop stars" she's doing fine considering only a couple are selling more than her, and not by that much...

The fact that it's been over 7 months since it has been released and it still hasn't gone platinum really says a lot. The album flopped.

ARTPOP WASNT A FLOP. SMH

No.
But it's a flop for Gaga haself.

Underperformance, the era itself is earning Gaga millions.