Am I the only wrong who thinks the 2nd one is the best?

No, I think the 2nd is the best too

But the 3rd is just a mess and the 4th one is very boring and predictable.

2 > 1 > 3 > 4, imo.

The 2nd one was the best.

MusicTalker's rating is accurate.

Davy Jones should snatch Maleficent's wig by releasing ha own movie!

Yep! I need 5 to be at least as good as 3 though.

1 > 2 > 4 = 3

The 4th one gets too much flack. It was a lot more light hearted than the previous 2 but it really reminded me of the first film in terms of freshness. The 3rd one was doing too much nearing the end but watching it a second time you appreciate it more.

DMC is quite overrated

3>1>2=4 imo

I loved the third one lol, been my favorite since I saw it in theaters.

The last one was trash.

DMC > AWE = COTBP > OST
OST is painful to watch

2. The only thing I really liked in 4 was Philip and Syrena, cliché as it might be.

1>>>2>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>3=/>>4

The final fight scene in Dead Man's Chest between Jack Sparrow, Will Turner and James Norrington >>>>>>

Not too much on Stranger Tides now. It was decent.

2 > 1 = 3 > 4

The first one is classic. DMC is entertaining. AWE was alright... The 4th...

1>>>>2>>3>>>4

I fell asleep watching Stranger Tides at the cinema.

2 > 1 > 3 > 4.

The one who's hilarious.

Dead Man's Chest.