Originally posted by SeanET

Lady Gaga - G.U.Y. video & G.U.Y. short version ---> 58 million views

Katy Perry - Birthday (lyric video) & original video ---> 58 million views

G.U.Y. was released earlier tho

Originally posted by SeanET

Lady Gaga - G.U.Y. video & G.U.Y. short version ---> 58 million views

Katy Perry - Birthday (lyric video) & original video ---> 58 million views

G.U.Y. was released earlier tho

Originally posted by Allie

I'd have to agree. Katy also brought innovative filming techniques to the table, which G.U.Y failed to do in addition to being unentertaining.

Originally posted by Allie

I'd have to agree. Katy also brought innovative filming techniques to the table, which G.U.Y failed to do in addition to being unentertaining.

Originally posted by SeanET

Lady Gaga - G.U.Y. video & G.U.Y. short version ---> 58 million views

Katy Perry - Birthday (lyric video) & original video ---> 58 million views

G.U.Y. was released earlier tho

Originally posted by Allie

I'd have to agree. Katy also brought innovative filming techniques to the table, which G.U.Y failed to do in addition to being unentertaining.

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

And Birthday has more airplay

Originally posted by Yzma

Seriously judging anyone that voted for Birthday.

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

And Birthday has more airplay

Originally posted by Dark_Lorde

This thread is comparing a music video of an artist who was given an extremely high budget due to her previous singles underperforming to a music video of an artist that had already racked up two number 1's and as such has a budget that needs to be spread out across multiple single releases.

It feels like you guys are just looking for things to say gaga is better at.

Anyways, Birthday is still the better video. It doesn't have the expensive stunning visuals of hearst castle but it's genuine. It's fun to watch.

I'd rather watch Katy Perry do a good deed and surprise people.

It makes me feel good inside to watch Birthday. I'm not really interested in the video that's basically saying lady gaga is a hybrid in music and she's rising like a phoenix.

I wanna watch the kids, laugh and smile about being surprised by a superstar.

Originally posted by Allie

I'd have to agree. Katy also brought innovative filming techniques to the table, which G.U.Y failed to do in addition to being unentertaining.

Originally posted by Dark_Lorde

This thread is comparing a music video of an artist who was given an extremely high budget due to her previous singles underperforming to a music video of an artist that had already racked up two number 1's and as such has a budget that needs to be spread out across multiple single releases.

It feels like you guys are just looking for things to say gaga is better at.

Anyways, Birthday is still the better video. It doesn't have the expensive stunning visuals of hearst castle but it's genuine. It's fun to watch.

I'd rather watch Katy Perry do a good deed and surprise people.

It makes me feel good inside to watch Birthday. I'm not really interested in the video that's basically saying lady gaga is a hybrid in music and she's rising like a phoenix.

I wanna watch the kids, laugh and smile about being surprised by a superstar.

Originally posted by Dark_Lorde

This thread is comparing a music video of an artist who was given an extremely high budget due to her previous singles underperforming to a music video of an artist that had already racked up two number 1's and as such has a budget that needs to be spread out across multiple single releases.

It feels like you guys are just looking for things to say gaga is better at.

Anyways, Birthday is still the better video. It doesn't have the expensive stunning visuals of hearst castle but it's genuine. It's fun to watch.

I'd rather watch Katy Perry do a good deed and surprise people.

It makes me feel good inside to watch Birthday. I'm not really interested in the video that's basically saying lady gaga is a hybrid in music and she's rising like a phoenix.

I wanna watch the kids, laugh and smile about being surprised by a superstar.