Beautiful, Hurt, Halo

Live to Tell
Halo

Everytime

Umm, it's Nobody's Home. But voted for I'm With You because that's also great. Everytime, Innocence, Because of You and The Harold Song also slay my life .

The first 3 options probably.

Beautiful and Stay

Underneath your clothes >>>>

I'm with you >>>>>

Out of these, Because Of You.

Where's Mariah, ha discography?

I love 1+1 reminds me of a Prince song.

This is the best ballad - http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=605849

but that song isn't even remembered

I would say Everybody Hurts but I don't know it counts as it gets somewhat upbeat with the drums.
If Sia becomes a pop girl then we have the new queen of ballads "Don't Bring Me Down" is so amazing and heartbreaking.

Because of You is the only one listed that's above average.

Thinking of You >>

Everytime >>>>>