There have been threads comparing the success of each album and comparing the quality of their production, but we haven't had a thread to compare track by track to decide which album is better, so I'll start:

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

As much as I love Gaga and ARTPOP, I must admit BEYONCÉ is a mindblowing album. The only song that didn't impress me was Pretty Hurts (good song but too mainstream). The toughest ones for me were DWUW vs Jealous and Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue (hard to pick between the powerful Gypsy and the beautiful Blue).

BEYONCÉ and it's not even close.

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower (Never heard Mary Jane and don't like Superpower)
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

EDIT: I have never even listen to Lady Gaga album. Only heard DWUW and Applause

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

ARTPOP but i love both albums tho.

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

Me too

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

NEXT

ARTPOP easily

yeah I haven't listened to ARTPOP since I downloaded that copy the week it leaked. I need to delete it from my iTunes

BEYONCÉ >

Aura vs Pretty Hurts
Venus vs Haunted
G.U.Y. vs Drunk in Love
Sexxx Dreams vs Blow
Jewels N' Drugs vs No Angel
MANiCURE vs Partition
Do What U Want vs Jealous
ARTPOP vs Rocket
Swine vs Mine
Donatella vs XO
Fashion! vs ***Flawless
Mary Jane Holland vs Superpower
Dope vs Heaven
Gypsy vs Applause vs Blue

.