That Brian Mansfield has covered Idol (sales and reviews) for many years. I don't see why these reviews from Idol people should count because to a certain degree there is predetermined bias. Brian was supposed to rate the album based on how good it is on its own and not rate him based if it has any a "Home style hit." It also surprises me that the review (if you can call it that since it is very short) is not in itself negative, but he gave a 2 1/2? What kinda bulls***
Mjsbigblog also chose to ignore his album release and bothered not to post about it.