|
Poll: Shakira VS J.Lo- More Impact?
View Poll Results: Shakira VS Jlo
|
Shakira
|
|
157 |
47.43% |
J.Lo
|
|
142 |
42.90% |
Equal amount of impact.
|
|
23 |
6.95% |
Neither left impact
|
|
9 |
2.72% |
Member Since: 3/31/2012
Posts: 23,576
|
I won't even waste my energy. We all know who's had more impact, especially in the music industry.
|
|
|
Banned
Member Since: 3/2/2014
Posts: 441
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Shakira Stan
I won't even waste my energy. We all know who's had more impact, especially in the music industry.
|
Yes we all know it's jlo.
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/5/2012
Posts: 8,875
|
The poll results explains it all. The girls who stan for the other one can remain seated.
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/15/2009
Posts: 23,385
|
Quote:
Originally posted by JLO_FeEN
The poll results explains it all. The girls who stan for the other one can remain seated.
|
Its hillarious how Atrl one day stans for a girl but if her album underperforms they run the other way. Lets revisit this after aka's "impact"
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 2,383
|
I love both and prefer Shakira but J.Lo has had a huge impact in music and is much bigger globally.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 15,836
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kurama
Shakira may have the best selling song of past deca, but JLo has the best selling remix album of last decade.
JLo has more classics than Shakira WW.
Shakir ahas more Vevo Certified because JLo was pretty much dead until 2011, and On The Floor is more watched than any Shakira video.
Sale el Sol outsold Love, right, but now Shakira is strugling to sell her new album.
JLo has only one ww tour, she is not known as a touring artist and yet she received the Billboard Icon Award before Shakira.
|
1. What an achievement. Everyone must be so jealous of her!
2. And somehow, Shakira´s classics managed to be more remembered
3. Waka Waka is in the very approximate range, but i´ll give you that
4. Not my fault that Shakira was able to stay relevant for all the lenght of her career
5. Explaining below
6. Not my fault that your fave wasnt able to tour for most of her career
5. "Sale el Sol outsold Love, right, but now Shakira is strugling to sell her new album."
WW sales:
Week - Love? vs. Shakira. - amount the Top 10 together sold those respective weeks
1 - 155K (#4) vs. 179K (#3) - 1,279,000 vs. 1,124,000
2 - 99K (#2) vs. 90K (#4) - 1,011,000 vs. 1,065,000
3 - 78K (#2) vs. 63K (#3) - 852,000 vs. 647,000
4 - 67K (#5) vs. 61K (#6) - 2,804,000 vs. 982,000
5 - 56K (#13) vs. 41K (#7) - 1,650,000 vs. 670,000
6 - 50K (#16) vs. 37K (#8) - 1,726,000 vs. 777,000
TOTAL = 505K vs. 471K - Top 10 = 9,322,000 vs. 5,265,000 (43% decrease)
So, despite the market being bigger and having a huge, record-breaking smash hit, Love? only managed to outsell Shakira´s new album for 34K. Slay i guess
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/15/2012
Posts: 4,046
|
Let me remain PRESSED. I clicked on "Neither left impact" accidentally instead of equal. Can a mod fix that?
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/31/2012
Posts: 23,576
|
Quote:
Originally posted by JLO_FeEN
The poll results explains it all. The girls who stan for the other one can remain seated.
|
Yo, ATRL's opinion means ****. If we asked the whole wide world, you and I know who would win.
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/15/2009
Posts: 23,385
|
Quote:
Originally posted by alestevens
1. What an achievement. Everyone must be so jealous of her!
2. And somehow, Shakira´s classics managed to be more remembered
3. Waka Waka is in the very approximate range, but i´ll give you that
4. Not my fault that Shakira was able to stay relevant for all the lenght of her career
5. Explaining below
6. Not my fault that your fave wasnt able to tour for most of her career
5. "Sale el Sol outsold Love, right, but now Shakira is strugling to sell her new album."
WW sales:
Week - Love? vs. Shakira. - amount the Top 10 together sold those respective weeks
1 - 155K (#4) vs. 179K (#3) - 1,279,000 vs. 1,124,000
2 - 99K (#2) vs. 90K (#4) - 1,011,000 vs. 1,065,000
3 - 78K (#2) vs. 63K (#3) - 852,000 vs. 647,000
4 - 67K (#5) vs. 61K (#6) - 2,804,000 vs. 982,000
5 - 56K (#13) vs. 41K (#7) - 1,650,000 vs. 670,000
6 - 50K (#16) vs. 37K (#8) - 1,726,000 vs. 777,000
TOTAL = 505K vs. 471K - Top 10 = 9,322,000 vs. 5,265,000 (43% decrease)
So, despite the market being bigger and having a huge, record-breaking smash hit, Love? only managed to outsell Shakira´s new album for 34K. Slay i guess
|
fjksfjksdl;fjsdkafl;jasdkfl;
aka her "impact" is near.. her and all her buzz singles!
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/5/2012
Posts: 8,875
|
Quote:
Originally posted by GlitterBitch
I love both and prefer Shakira but J.Lo has had a huge impact in music and is much bigger globally.
|
Preach gal
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/5/2012
Posts: 8,875
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Shakira Stan
Yo, ATRL's opinion means ****. If we asked the whole wide world, you and I know who would win.
|
Ofc J.Lo.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/2/2014
Posts: 1,180
|
Quote:
Originally posted by alestevens
1. What an achievement. Everyone must be so jealous of her!
2. And somehow, Shakira´s classics managed to be more remembered
3. Waka Waka is in the very approximate range, but i´ll give you that
4. Not my fault that Shakira was able to stay relevant for all the lenght of her career
5. Explaining below
6. Not my fault that your fave wasnt able to tour for most of her career
5. "Sale el Sol outsold Love, right, but now Shakira is strugling to sell her new album."
WW sales:
Week - Love? vs. Shakira. - amount the Top 10 together sold those respective weeks
1 - 155K (#4) vs. 179K (#3) - 1,279,000 vs. 1,124,000
2 - 99K (#2) vs. 90K (#4) - 1,011,000 vs. 1,065,000
3 - 78K (#2) vs. 63K (#3) - 852,000 vs. 647,000
4 - 67K (#5) vs. 61K (#6) - 2,804,000 vs. 982,000
5 - 56K (#13) vs. 41K (#7) - 1,650,000 vs. 670,000
6 - 50K (#16) vs. 37K (#8) - 1,726,000 vs. 777,000
TOTAL = 505K vs. 471K - Top 10 = 9,322,000 vs. 5,265,000 (43% decrease)
So, despite the market being bigger and having a huge, record-breaking smash hit, Love? only managed to outsell Shakira´s new album for 34K. Slay i guess
|
ATTENTION TO THIS POST. I'M THROWING THE FACTS WITH NO PITY
2. Which Shakira classics are you talking about? Hips Don't Lie? This is the only instant classic, while JLo has many very memorable like IYHML/WFT/LGL/LDCT/IR/AIT/JFTB/GR/OTF etc. Shakira has had some hits, but not many as memorable as JLo's. #fact
3. Waka Waka is not at a very approximate range (100 million difference). YOU LIED WHEN YOU SAID THAT. On The Floor surpassed Waka Waka, remember that WW was released one year before On The Floor. #fact.
4. Shakira stayed relevant, while yet Jlo receives the Icon award, it shows who is trully relevant.
5. Girl, It's not like the market decreased in 43% since 2011, don't make up this data! You have to keep in mind that in 2011 There was the Huge Adele, there was also Born This Way and Mars selling pretty well at that time and may others big acts releasing at the same time of Jennifer. What big competition does Shakira have now aside Frozen? Get your facts together.
6. It's not your fault that my fave wasn't touring because she was busy becoming the MOST POWERFUL AND INFLUENTIAL LATIN ARTIST OF ALL THE TIME.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 15,836
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kurama
And about the touring, it's not like Shakira is a Huge Touring act, cause she is not.
Artist: Shakira
Rank: # 72
Gross: 4.3 million
Average Ticket Price: 37.27
Average Tickets: 38.705
Average Gross: 1,442,492
Cities/Shows: 3/4
Pollstar Top 50 Worldwide Tour (first half of 2011)
Shakira $39.9 million (47 shows)
Adding the 16.9 million earned from first leg in USA (24 shows, average gross $768,182),we have $ 56.8 million from 71 shows
SHAKIRA MADE ONLY 56.8 million dollars in her 71 first shows from her last tour (which had more than 100 concerts) while JLo made 75 million from 73 concerts from her first ww tour.
|
The lies:
2011 top WW tours of 2011:
http://www.pollstarpro.com/charts/20...dwideTours.pdf
Shakira - $53.2 Million in 51 dates
2010 top North American tours of 2010:
http://www.pollstarpro.com/files/Cha...ricanTours.pdf
Shakira - $16.9 Million in 24 dates
Total = $70,1 Millions in 75 dates. The tour had over 100 dates, and the ones missing are mostly stadium dates in Latin America, so you do the math
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 17,161
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/2/2014
Posts: 1,180
|
Quote:
Originally posted by alestevens
|
YOU ARE THE ONE LYING.
Here is the source with all information from the TSCO WT posted by a Shaki Stan with detailed information and sources for what i posted. Learn your homework first..
http://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopi...7456&start=375
She made $ 56.8 million from 71 shows and you gotta deal with it. And even if she made 70 million in 75 dates, she would be still be behind JLo considering the same quantity of concerts.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/2/2014
Posts: 1,180
|
I have to also say that the only big thing Shaki is doing now is The Voice, and she is only doing it because JLo opened the doors for her.
If Jennifer didn't succeed at American Idol no other pop girl would join talent shows.
Now I REST MY CASE, NOW I GOTTA RELAX MY HAIR.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 15,836
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kurama
ATTENTION TO THIS POST. I'M THROWING THE FACTS WITH NO PITY
2. Which Shakira classics are you talking about? Hips Don't Lie? This is the only instant classic, while JLo has many very memorable like IYHML/WFT/LGL/LDCT/IR/AIT/JFTB/GR/OTF etc. Shakira has had some hits, but not many as memorable as JLo's. #fact
3. Waka Waka is not at a very approximate range (100 million difference). YOU LIED WHEN YOU SAID THAT. On The Floor surpassed Waka Waka, remember that WW was released one year before On The Floor. #fact.
4. Shakira stayed relevant, while yet Jlo receives the Icon award, it shows who is trully relevant.
5. Girl, It's not like the market decreased in 43% since 2011, don't make up this data! You have to keep in mind that in 2011 There was the Huge Adele, there was also Born This Way and Mars selling pretty well at that time and may others big acts releasing at the same time of Jennifer. What big competition does Shakira have now aside Frozen? Get your facts together.
6. It's not your fault that my fave wasn't touring because she was busy becoming the MOST POWERFUL AND INFLUENTIAL LATIN ARTIST OF ALL THE TIME.
|
2. Their videos from before the VEVO era with more than 10M in order (in red: J.Lo videos):
Hips Dont Lie - 164 Million views
Whenever, Wherever - 156 Million views
La Tortura - 106 Million views
Aint It Funny (Alt. Version) - 52 Million views
Suerte - 42 Million views
Te Aviso, Te Anuncio - 40 Million views
If You Had My Love - 39 Million views
Jenny From The Block - 35 Million views
Im Real - 33 Million views
Las De La Intuicion - 33 Million views
Get Right - 31 Million views
Love Dont Cost A Thing - 26 Million views
Dont Bother - 24 Million views
Underneath Your Clothes - 23 Million views
Que Hiciste - 20 Million views
Waiting For Tonight - 19 Million views
Lets Get Loud - 19 Million views
Do It Well - 16 Million views
No - 15 Million views
All I Have - 13 Million views
Play - 12 Million views
Ojos Así - 11 Million views
Illegal - 10 Million views
Que Me Quedes Tu - 10 Million views
4- Delusion at its finest
5- Pharrell Williams, the one with the biggest hit of the year
and Katy Perry is still selling well
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 9,522
|
Shakira for sure.
Hips Don't Lie & WW >> La Lopez career.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 15,836
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kurama
YOU ARE THE ONE LYING.
Here is the source with all information from the TSCO WT posted by a Shaki Stan with detailed information and sources for what i posted. Learn your homework first..
http://www.ukmix.org/forums/viewtopi...7456&start=375
She made $ 56.8 million from 71 shows and you gotta deal with it. And even if she made 70 million in 75 dates, she would be still be behind JLo considering the same quantity of concerts.
|
Not an UKmix user being more reliable than Pollstar now. I have seen it all
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/9/2010
Posts: 31,471
|
Tough but I'll go with J Lo
|
|
|
|
|