Member Since: 12/24/2010
Posts: 37,039
|
Team Cheryl
Taylor Swift
Cheryl:
Not her best.
Simon:
The cover is simple and beautiful but it feels like something is missing. The background could be filled.
Nicole:
Everything is really really good. The pose, good. Her look very fierce and that hairstyle is perfect! However, that dress is horrible. Ugly cut, material is tacky and that colour is a no no. If it was a LBD or something different honestly I’d be giving it a 10 but that dress is a big turn off.
Miley:
Her hair looks great here but the dress is just way too ugly. It looks like a beehive decided to take a trip to the 1970s and make a disco dress at a fashion factory.
Madonna:
Love the dress + the hair
Sky:
Something is off with the face because of the hair, but besides that. WOW, was not ready for that. The sexy spring umbrella dress is slaying on her.
Rihanna
Cheryl:
Nope.
Simon:
The only mistake is the backround. Apart from that She looks F***** hot and it's fierce as hell 
Nicole:
Hmm..not sure I like this. It’s a bit, skanky. It’s trying to be fierce and I can see it but fails. It just doesn’t work as a whole.
Miley:
At first I thought this would be an easy 8 to 10 ranking for you, but what ruined this cover for me was her face. She looks too manish here. Her hair reminds me of what my hair looks like when it's down and her eyes look weird here. Her face usually looks a lot better in fierce photoshoots like this.
Madonna:
Her body looks weird. 
Sky:
Perfection. Only Rihanna could pull this off. Everything about this is perfect, including the image quality of the image you sent. Some of the ones around you were blurry, so slay a bit.
Little Mix
Cheryl:
This was so stressing for us and this was the best
Simon:
It's too much "information" on the cover. Their poses + all the words on them ruins the chances of it being the "best cover"
Nicole:
I think I don’t really need to make much of a comment on this one. May I just ask did you not see their Fabulous cover?
Miley:
The magazine cover has the exact word to describe this right in front of their pose - CUTE. It's not fierce. it's just cute. High School cute.
Madonna:
I'm sorry but that cover isn't fierce at all. Seventeen 
Sky:
I'm sorry, but this looks really what's it called, Tiger Beat, or whatever those preteen magazines are called. Either the group cover or individual ones would have been better choices.
Team Simon
Girls Aloud
Cheryl:
Their make up and hair are perfect, they're outfits the pits.
Simon:
The cover is totally original and different. Everything is on point on that cover (poses' outfits, colours)
Nicole:
I actually like almost all of it. The concept is good but Nicole looks awful. What’s worse is it’s the most distracting person as well. Aside from her and a few odd facial expressions, it’s a decent entry.
Miley:
This is what Little Mix failed to do. They look elegant, fierce, mature and gorgeous.
Madonna:
YAS. Show little mix how is done. 
Sky:
Really a good cover for a girl group They all look stunning and like powerful people.
Team Miley
Beyonce
Cheryl:
Her hair looks weird.
Simon:
I would prefer to see some colour but apart from that i love it
Nicole:
Very, very near perfect! I love that black and white idea. The pose and outfit is fierce. I just have a slight issue with her face, not sure if it’s the shadowing or the wind that’s blowing but looks a bit odd.
Miley:
Just want to let everyone know that I didn't even bother messaging Bey this round since he's never replied with me whenever I messaged him in previous rounds aside from the first round. As for this cover, again, her pose looks fierce but everything surrounding it is too weird. What's the point of all the words jumbled up behind her and the cameras hanging on her if this is supposed to be a style and design issue? I mean  It just doesn't make sense.
Madonna:
wow, this cover is amazing. good job! 
Sky:
Gorgeous stunning image. Just a cover that feels special. Bey is serving Wind Goddess here.
Christina Aguilera
Cheryl:
Very religious, I love it.
Simon:
She looks great and all but it's too simple to call it "the best cover"
Nicole:
Again plain just like Taylors and I gave you the same score as I think you’re on similar territory. Not much I can say here. Nothing I absolutely hate, but likewise nothing for me to completely love.
Miley:
We slayed this round E. Elegant, gorgeous and fierce all at the same time.
Madonna:
She looks beautiful! but I don't see what's fierce about this cover. 
Sky:
It's a pretty image. But not compelling or special in anyway possible. Could be anyone. Usually more "fashion" covers are stronger. Christina has stronger international covers , and that naked W cover would have been better.
Team Nicole
Britney Spears
Cheryl:
LEGEND.
Simon:
Even thinging the cover it's quite iconic i'm sure Britney has better covers. I'm sorry if i'm committing a mistake saying this.
Nicole:
Perfect. It’s one of Britney’s iconic ones and she is very very simplistic but that’s how you pull it off. Well done.
Miley:
You finally got it right. Your first 10 from me. But don't let the delusional Britney stans think that you always deserve 10s because Britney isn't perfect. Her stans put her on too high of a pedestal sometimes so it really annoys me when I have the nerve to express my opinion while judging her and not give her a 10 just because I don't think she deserves one and people have the nerve to say I'm not a fair judge. When she deserves a 10, she'll get it. And this round she definitely deserved it.
Madonna:
Perfect.
Sky:
Girl, this **** is straight up ratchet. Like look at this queen serving SEX.
Shakira
Cheryl:
Her expression isn't the right one.
Simon:
Just like the name of the magazine she look fabulous  i love the scenario, the outfit and her look!
Nicole:
I grouped you with Beyonce as I thought just like her, love the outfit and her hair and pose is pretty brilliant. However her face is slightly odd there and that jaw isn’t her best look.
Miley:
This isn't perfect, but it's pretty fierce enough for an 8 from me.
Madonna:
The expression on her face ruined the cover but it's still a good entry.
Sky:
She looks strong. That's one of the saving graces of this, she looks in control. But it's not particularly compelling otherwise.
Team Madonna
Lady Gaga
Cheryl:
Team Madonna doesn't need anyone else to slay the other groups, bow down bishes.
Simon:
It's AMAZING! Everything is perfect! the iconic bra 
Nicole:
After seeing your cover last, I must say it’s the best! I was expecting an ugly Gaga or avant-garde one which we know are hit and miss. But I love this retro, fierce one. The bra, perfect. Her hair is the best shade and that lipstick. Honestly, all the makings of a classic.
Miley:
Bye. She looks like she's drooling in her sleep while having a live action nightmare. Not fierce at all. Just gross.
Madonna:
I'm glad you chose this cover  The pyro-bra alone >
Sky:
It's a strong cover. Has that special feeling to it.
Team Sky
Katy Perry
Cheryl:
Oh My God, her boobs.
Simon:
The background could be different but she looks hot and the make up is perfect. Not the best cover but it stands out
Nicole:
Does she not have any other fierce ones? I thought THIS was your round! I kept saying you’d have it. But I feel a little disappointed. Yeah her big balloons are pretty good and I do like what she attempted with her arms but after that, it’s boring. But not extremely bad, so I can’t penalise you for anything much. Just feeling a little…sad. I wanted to see some fierce glamour and beauty from her.
Miley:
Very fierce pose. Katy really knows how to dip into to her sexual expressions.
Madonna:
It's time to bring out the big balloons. 
Sky:
Sex goddess. This sells on a stand. This resides in-between teen boy mattresses.
Kylie Minogue
Cheryl:
Saggy boobs.
Simon:
it's definitely it's not her best cover.
she doesn't fill that bikini
Nicole:
I like this a lot. Her hairstyle is on point and that sultry face is by far the best facial expression of this round. After that everything becomes slightly bland. The pose and swimwear doesn’t really impress or help in anyway. But that isn’t a huge downside so still a good entry!
Miley:
She was really gorgeous back when she was young. So natural looking too. She was drop dead fierce in this so well done.
Madonna:
She looks hot! that swimsuit is ugly tho
Sky:
This cover is peculiar. I appreciate that it is an older cover. This is very fashionable for its time. But my taste is contemporary. So there's a level of resistance to my appreciation of it. But i love how on trend it once was.
|
|
|
|
Judges
