Point out where i said Madonna can sing better? - i said they both have average vocal rang and, they do. If i had to make a choice, i would indeed say gaga can sing, slightly better. but SLIGHTLY. certainly not the way you're making it out to be.
No again, Madonna and gaga's vocal ability is similar. Gaga is no Mariah Carey or Celine Dion. They are BOTH in the average category.
Take a listen to gaga's mic feed without the pre recorded magic.
LOL. Why don't you listen to a real performance here:
If you set Mariah or Celine as standard, then Gaga could be average, but Madonna is just inferior.
LOL. Why don't you listen to a real performance here:
If you set Mariah or Celine as standard, then Gaga could be average, but Madonna is just inferior.
Your reply just proves exactly what I said. Did you not read my comment?
Quote:
Gaga has her good moments: when she is sitting still and only moving her hands to play the piano. Those are the only moments she sounds good and doesn’t rely on pre-recorded vocals to cover up her bad vocals.
Thank you for providing a video of the very example that I described. Not sure what the point was though but thank you.
Quote:
Madonna can dace and sing at the same time, she has the resistance and the control, and unlike Gaga, Madonna does not need layers of pre-recorded vocals in her backtrack in every song she dances.
I provided a video to support that.
Thank you, so much for doing the work for me.
Madonna's inferior because you say so. Despite the fact as stated by someone else her vocal range is actually a little higher, despite the fact Madonna can dance and sing at the same time as shown in the video, despite the fact gaga uses pre recorded vocals and sounds awful without them when she dances at the same time, Madonna is inferior. - Make sense
Point out where i said Madonna can sing better? - i said they both have average vocal rang and, they do. If i had to make a choice, i would indeed say gaga can sing, slightly better. but SLIGHTLY. certainly not the way you're making it out to be.
No again, Madonna and gaga's vocal ability is similar. Gaga is no Mariah Carey or Celine Dion. They are BOTH in the average category.
Take a listen to gaga's mic feed without the pre recorded magic.
Where is the pre recorded magic here?
Why would you choose a heavily electronic track which is heavily choreographed (for Gaga's standards!) to show vocal ability. Madonna's vocal prowess comes nowhere near Gaga's in the above video. That's not really a bad thing...that's not really why Madonna was such a force anyway, so I don't know why you're defending it so much
Gaga can sing better while not dancing, not even a competition
Madonna doesn't sing that much while she dances -- receipts that say otherwise?
Range has little to do with who is a better singer when comparing two singers - look at Adele!
Why would you choose a heavily electronic track which is heavily choreographed (for Gaga's standards!) to show vocal ability. Madonna's vocal prowess comes nowhere near Gaga's in the above video. That's not really a bad thing...that's not really why Madonna was such a force anyway, so I don't know why you're defending it so much
READ WHAT I WROTE.
Quote:
Gaga has her good moments: when she is sitting still and only moving her hands to play the piano. Those are the only moments she sounds good and doesn’t rely on pre-recorded vocals to cover up her bad vocals.
No, you're just aware that Lady Gaga is a much better singer than Madonna so you're trying hard to make it seem like she's not. Madonna doesn't even dance and sing at the same time that often...and if she does, the choreography is simple.
Why would you choose a heavily electronic track which is heavily choreographed (for Gaga's standards!) to show vocal ability. Madonna's vocal prowess comes nowhere near Gaga's in the above video. That's not really a bad thing...that's not really why Madonna was such a force anyway, so I don't know why you're defending it so much
Gaga can sing better while not dancing, not even a competition
Madonna doesn't sing that much while she dances -- receipts that say otherwise?
Range has little to do with who is a better singer when comparing two singers - look at Adele!
