Sis, no. I'm of the opinion that ...BOMT had considerably more impact, but we still need to give Christina credit where credit is due. Beautiful is hugely impactful, even if it's not as impactful as ...BOMT. We don't need to resort to invalidating a woman's accomplishments to make Britney's look better

I heard Mean Girls was written in a more tongue in cheek/sophisticated kind of humor way though, so that might not be too bad. I guess I'll have to watch it someday to see what it's about

Impact where?

Aside from ATRL, Twitter and Youtube (Brit's desperate stans) where?

The song isn't even played on radio, not covered on TV shows, not even in iTunes charts.

Clearly ''Beautiful'' it's more familiarized with GP.

You've came a long way.
I don't even like Britney anymore, but I still feel like her debut single was, like the biggest ever lol. The schoolgirl impact was real, and besides the media depicting her terribly in 2007, remains what people recognize her for.
Even though I agree, Beautiful is probably played a lot more on radio, covered in competitions, selling more now, and everything. I guess for "iconic" BOMT's image wins out, but as a song, Beautiful wins out.
Idk, "iconic" is so subjective and a terrible thing to measure lol.

Bigger =/= Impact

Everybody knows that BOMT WAS like waaaay bigger. But impact as today! No way.

educate them

This. End thread.


not gimme more being more remembered than xtina's signature song.

Vevo views =/= Impact

So "I Wanna Go" is more remembered and has more impact than the best seller song of all time (I Gotta Feeling) because of the Vevo views?

You cant compare a video that premiered during the VEVO era with one that didnt. But since neither BOMT nor Beautiful premiered during the VEVO era, it is actually a fair comparison

but I gotta feeling has more views than I wanna go, so no

Yeah. Both videos were uploaded the same year, 2009

The landslide.

...Baby One More Time

Both are absolutely massive, well remembered, and are pop masterpieces.

I voted for ...BOMT simply because of how iconic every single thing associated with it is, from her "baby coo" voice, the schoolgirl outfit, the suggestive, memorable lyrics, and the instantly recognizable opening three-note piano motif.

BOMT

for xtina fans: Beautiful

For everyone else: BOMT