Wow.

The most I have of an artist is like 15 lol

I am the biggest PCD fan you'll ever find. I bought them all too.

tpain, akon, "lookin boy" etc etc

what is the definition of good music?

well let me tell you its when i like it!!!!

just kidding but the defintion of good music is when it's catchy and easy on the ears

Talented Artist

Well there's different kinds of "Good Music", like for me there's music that I may enjoy but I know it's really pretty bad music deep down. I do believe there's some music that you can say it's objectively bad in terms of quality and effort put into it, though ENJOYABILITY is another factor and some objectively bad music is still enjoyable even if it's crap. Some bad music is merely entertaining and people like it for that. I like Rihanna but I don't really think she's "good music" in the strict definition of the word. On the other hand someone like Alicia Keys I could say that they're good music.

No. Talented artists can put out **** records even if they can belt a song or so. Good material along with a catchy hook, an optional good message and a good beat help to create good music.

Like Back to Basics

there's no such thing as definition of good music for me, coz I think it's undefinable
I'm such a wise man

I hate to bump this damn thread up, but I need to speak my mind on the matter.

First of all, I'm dying of laughter at those who are taking Kworb's stance on Oasis so seriously. For one, I mean, SURELY people know not to take Kworb that seriously, right? Secondly, I think he knows that what he's saying really is an opinion, but he knows that he can get a rise out of you guys, so he does it.

Okay, anywho, the topic on hand...

"Good Music", as pointed out, is in the eye of the beholder. Period. Anyone who says otherwise is an ignorant tool.

Now, does this immediately stop me from pointing out when someone's taste does not co-exist with mine? Not right away, no.. But I completely realize that people will listen to whatever the **** they want to listen to, even if I can't stand the songs myself, and I can't stop them from listening. If they enjoy it, THEY enjoy it. I mean, hell, I'm sure that quite a few people would have problems with *my* taste, so it's all relative and it's all opinion. I understand that.

Am I a fan of Jesse McCartney's music? No. Am I a fan of Rihanna's music? Not really, no. But it's not MY place to decide what music people should listen to. "Good Music" is what you make of it, whether that be Chris Brown or The Mars Volta or Beck or Carrie Underwood or any other musician or group of musicians.