Poll: Hips Dont Lie vs Crazy In Love - More Iconic ? - Page 8

TeemoR

Hips dont lie but i dont care i voted for CIL

Summertime Love

Quote:

Originally posted by Jaime

Crazy in Love by far.

I don't even know who sings the other song.

Quote:

Originally posted by Shakira Stan

The only reason CIL will win the poll is because ATRL's filled with the hive...

Sistrens...

Anyway, CIL wins it for me.

Amira

Quote:

Originally posted by yuiki

I'm a 23 years old latin guy and I can honestly say I didn't even listen to CIL until 2007. You are highly overestimating the reach of CiL. Like I said before, it's an amazing song and one of Beyonce's best and most iconic songs. However it is mostly remembered in the US, because that's where it was known the most. It might be more iconic to you since you were more exposed to it than a lot of people, but you can't force your opinion on everyone else, when most people (as backed up by the poll) are telling you they believe HDL is more iconic, and they remember it better. And it's not only about it selling so much more than CiL, it's about it being a hit that pretty much became synonymous to one of the biggest pop stars in the world.

CIL was huge in Europe too, some people are just too young to remember.

Zano

Crazy in live by far. Hips don't lie was huge in 2006.. But it sounds dated right now while CIL still sounds fresh. People still cover CIL on shows like Idols/X-factor and the voice.

22 Two's

this poll joins a lot of others thread in the category called "invalid": a lot of beyhaters runing here while they dont even remember hips dont lie instrumental to begin; have a good day!

22 Two's

Quote:

Originally posted by Zano

Crazy in live by far. Hips don't lie was huge in 2006.. But it sounds dated right now while CIL still sounds fresh. People still cover CIL on shows like Idols/X-factor and the voice.

this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! im done with beyhaters. lets go down the streets and ask normal pple if they remember CIL & HDL. we'll see.

i already got my answer

Miss Korea

Hips Do NOT Lie

manwhore

Quote:

Originally posted by 22 Two's

this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! im done with beyhaters. lets go down the streets and ask normal pple if they remember CIL & HDL. we'll see.

i already got my answer

Do those happen the be U.S. STREETS. Lol jk but yeah that wasn't a good example bro

Beyy

The lies in here

Crazy In Love is not more successful then HDL, maybe on local scale (Colombia or Brazil for example), but in other countries CIL = HDL or CIL > HDL.

Also, HDL doesn't sound dated. Same for CIL. Both sound fresh and are the most iconic pop songs of this Millennium.

Both have iconic lines and iconic music videos.

If you look at Spotify plays, CIL has more plays (20M) vs 16M..
But on YouTube HDL has more.
iTunes are around the same.
Both are 100% iconic.

Giancor

Shakira, Shakira alone >>>>