Originally posted by iHypeMusic What? makes no sense, STOP. He had a problem with the act being dragged despite her doing it. I'm saying people NOW have a problem because this is their first time seeing this happen. How is that a hard concept to grasp? Delusion really hurts some of y'all.

So just so I'm clear you're arguing that:

The 200M+ grossing tour that was one of the most popular things of her career was just some thing for the stans that no one knew about it.

This SXSW festival set that had 23,000 viewers on the LiveStream as the peak is this huge moment of her career that everyone is focused on?

And again, it doesn't really matter whether people knew about it or not. If they're saying "Well she's desperate for doing it now," they are wrong because she's done it before. Just because you're unaware of something, that doesn't mean it never happened. Take a deep breath. They can react all they want, but that doesn't mean their reactions are factual.

Originally posted by qmpierre Oh my gosh, you all on here are the worst. You are a parent, your kid is going to puke on you sometime. You go to a college party, chances are you could get puked on. It happened let it go. It is gross yes but I would rather someone not be a fricking pansy about vomit. The day katy perry gets on stage and fists a guy is the day i start stanning for her because that means she truly has guts and doesn't give a rat's butt what anyone thinks. Thats being true to who you are. when you don't give a ****. You can call this a publicity stunt but if it was a publicity stunt she would of done this at the grammys or something of that sort but instead she did it at a small festival where she told the audience to put their cameras and phones away. So keep trying.

Cannot tell if joking or serious

Originally posted by Corefield Gaga stans acting like we're stupid and not getting the message. I'm sure everybody is smart enough to get it, but the message could have been delivered with a lot more class. That's why it's turning a lot of people off, it comes off as desperate. Who cares if she did it in the past in front of her fans, she did it on camera in front of people who are NOT her fans. It was tasteless and a very dumb move.

Originally posted by J. YONCÉ So just so I'm clear you're arguing that: The 200M+ grossing tour that was one of the most popular things of her career was just some thing for the stans that no one knew about it. This SXSW festival set that had 23,000 viewers on the LiveStream as the peak is this huge moment of her career that everyone is focused on? And again, it doesn't really matter whether people knew about it or not. If they're saying "Well she's desperate for doing it now," they are wrong because she's done it before. Just because you're unaware of something, that doesn't mean it never happened. Take a deep breath. They can react all they want, but that doesn't mean their reactions are factual.

Originally posted by iHypeMusic girl I don't give a **** if her tour did $23 billion in gross. You cannot expect an average person to went to her monster ball and have seen it live. The ****? Especially if it's her haters. Common sense isn't your forte.

Originally posted by qmpierre Oh my gosh, you all on here are the worst. You are a parent, your kid is going to puke on you sometime. You go to a college party, chances are you could get puked on.

Originally posted by J. YONCÉ We're not talking about "average people," we're talking about ATRL members. And again, it doesn't matter if they weren't aware of it. She still already did it. People are entitled to hate the performance. But to say it's a "new low" or "desperate" for her doesn't make sense because it IS something she's already done, whether or not her "haters" are aware of it. That's the point I'm trying to make. I really don't get why you're so angry about this.

Originally posted by J. YONCÉ So what? Why should she care about them? If they're not her fans they can turn it off.

Originally posted by iHypeMusic So if she stabbed someone without us knowing and she did it prior before we don't have the right to get annoyed since she's done it before? Even if we never knew? Log off.

Originally posted by Corefield I never said she should, I'm just stating that it is normal for people who haven't been to her tour to find this disgusting.

Originally posted by Graduation Your incoherent ramblings aren't helping with this conversation. I don't understand what the big deal is. I think it's more funny/ridiculous than gross. Not sure if that's what she was going for, but she continues to devolve into a caricature of herself. And it's stuff like this that makes her lyrics such as "I love the music / not the bling" sound much less genuine. This is clearly a stunt to get people talking (it worked), but literally no one is talking about the music.

Originally posted by J. YONCÉ Causing someone bodily harm and injury is not the same thing as doing something kind of gross with a performance artist. Please stop being so rude to me when I've said absolutely nothing rude to you.