Poll: Beyonce The Voice of this generation ? - Page 6

Doc

Quote:

Originally posted by atrlster

Nope, no one but her fans think that

So untrue.

atrlster

Quote:

Originally posted by DejaVu

You always try so hard too. It's kind of endearing

If there's anyone who's a try hard, you're the definition of that

vuelve88

Quote:

Originally posted by atrlster

What kind of logic is that?

They were not interviewing her for a tour. You obviously haven't seen the entire interview

Reread what you even posted
"It'll barely allow me to sort of get back to my fans, maybe see them on the road, have some tour dates possibly."
Talk about you taking what she said she spinning it into something totally different. There was nothing ever confirmed. She thought of the possibility doing a rock album too. According to vuelve88 logic, that was cancelled too

The only person that's trying is you trying to make you know who happen

Again, after having her last tour cancelled, Christina and her team were taking a more cautious approach and hedging their bets. She talked multiple times about taking a break to tour.

It's on the internet. There is proof. You can't pretend it never happened just because it doesn't work in your favor. Lol

I mean, she didn't even get a legitimate video for her second single. LOL. That's how little faith her record label has in her.

Get Em CiCi

Quote:

Originally posted by Doc

So untrue.

It's actually one of the only true things that were said in this thread.

You're only saying that because you ARE a Beyoncé fan, of course you're gonna say that, that's the argument proving itself right.

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by CosmicLover

You can sit there and argue all day but the fact is Christina has two major awards on her mantle that say People's VOICE and VOICE of a Generation. Them's facts my dear. Time to pack it in.

Beyonce is a great performer that can sing but voice of a generation she is not. And lol @ lack of power. That's cute coming from a Beyonce fan. Let's not even get into Beyonce's head voice. There's a reason why the greats always say Christina Aguilera. Patti, Whitney, Celine, Aretha...shall I go on?

Please. Beyonce has been praised by all those girls and by more people, much more people,+ Bey also has more awards and more prestigious vocalist awards(See Grammys) than X Tina.

And for real? Head voice? Beyonce's is perfect! It's much better than those pitchy unsupported falsettos that the other girl does.

SuccesLovato

Demi is ... BYE!

aaronsmithjune1

As of right now it's

Beyonce

Kelly - very close behind

Christina - 10 years ago she would have been #1 ,but her voice is a mess now.but with some training she could easily do better

atrlster

Quote:

Originally posted by vuelve88

Again, after having her last tour cancelled, Christina and her team were taking a more cautious approach and hedging their bets. She talked multiple times about taking a break to tour.

It's on the internet. There is proof. You can't pretend it never happened just because it doesn't work I your favor. Lol

I mean, she didn't even get a legitimate video for her second single. LOL. That's how little faith her record label has in her.

Not you acting you're part of Christina's team and knowing her inner thoughts and plans lol

Again, I know she talked about the possibility of touring, but it was never anything she actually wanted to do or actually set into motion to actually doing. Again, that's like saying she has a cancelled rock album.

Her not doing a video s probably more her doing not theirs. They were actively pushing the song on radio and the song did pretty well in sales given its low airplay, but she already zoned out by then.

Sunshine.

Yes. Beyoncé is until we see more from the others. To be the voice of generation, you need to be more than just a good singer. Beyoncé is constantly improvising new ways to deliver vocals and pushing her voice to expand it's capability.

Kelly and Xtina and the rest just sing outright. No flavor, no innovation. A Celine-sized mess. Even Mariah and Whitney were known for trying new things with their vocals.

atrlster

Quote:

Originally posted by Get Em CiCi

It's actually one of the only true things that were said in this thread.

You're only saying that because you ARE a Beyoncé fan, of course you're gonna say that, that's the argument proving itself right.

!!!!

Like seriously, he just proved my point right there and then

DejaVu

Quote:

Originally posted by aaronsmithjune1

As of right now it's

Beyonce

Kelly - very close behind

Christina - 10 years ago she would have been #1 ,but her voice is a mess now.but with some training she could easily do better :micheal:

Some training can help her from damaging her instrument any further, but it will take years and years for her to fully recover her throat. Maybe even surgery à la Adele.

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by Get Em CiCi

It's actually one of the only true things that were said in this thread.

You're only saying that because you ARE a Beyoncé fan, of course you're gonna say that, that's the argument proving itself right.

Answer me this. If X Tina is the voice of our generation, why don't more than 300k people by her album?

I mean, look at Beyonce. Over 800k people, just in the U.S., bought hers in the first week. And that was with no previews of what it would sound like. It was her and her voice that did that.

CosmicLover

Quote:

Originally posted by Timber

Please. Beyonce has been praised by all those girls and by more people, much more people,+ Bey also has more awards and more prestigious vocalist awards(See Grammys) than X Tina.

And for real? Head voice? Beyonce's is perfect! It's much better than those pitchy unsupported falsettos that the other girl does.

The delusion. LOL @ prestigious vocalist awards. But has she gotten a 'voice of this generation award' or a specific award saying she's the 'People's Voice'? That's the real tea here. That is what we are discussing. You can sit there and talk about all the accolades Beyonce has but is she on the Times 100 influential people list with an article written by CELINE DION about how great she is or Rolling Stone's 100 greatest artists of all time?! Nope!

Beyonce's head voice is one of the worst I've heard. Christina could wipe the floor with Beyonce's weak head voice any day. We should try to see if Beyonce could even pull off a song like A Song For You. God knows how bad that could be with what she did to At Last.

Ethanrih

Why are people mentions tours/sales. This is about talent. Y'all are just trying to change the subject.

LEGENDB

Quote:

Originally posted by Bloo

The OP asked if there were other artists that sound better live than in the studio, I then proceeded to say Kelly sounds better live (than in the studio). Reading comprehension, you tried it.

Also, Kelly is the only one of the two that actually only uses her voice in her performances, so that point literally makes no sense based on the styles of the artists.

A lip sync drag? Cute.

Her fans, while on tour, pay top dollar for such performances. And the critics aren't rating themselves

Sunshine.

Quote:

Originally posted by Timber

Answer me this. If X Tina is the voice of our generation, why don't more than 300k people by her album?

I mean, look at Beyonce. Over 800k people, just in the U.S., bought hers in the first week. And that was with no previews of what it would sound like. It was her and her voice that did that.

We should probably just keep this vocally related to avoid being off-topic. Everyone knows Xtina's a flop (sorry for being blunt), but you wouldn't say Britney is a better vocalist just because she happen to sell more.

Vocally speaking, Xtina was revered. Today, she's fallen off harshly because she's neglected to take care of her voice. It's that simple. She could have been (she has a nicer tone than Bey), but realistically, she's not.

LEGENDB

Ciara, Christina, and Rihanna stans can't discuss vocals. Seriously.

I will not submit myself to arguing with stans of those who can't sing.

aaronsmithjune1

If your a great Singer when you first come out,the GP will always look at you in that light..that why Christina is looked at as the voice of the Gen.but Kelly and bey could sing laps around Christina.she hit the same sh*t over & over.Christina has more overall power.but Beyonce as a vocalist puts Christina to shame.

atrlster

Quote:

Originally posted by aaronsmithjune1

If your a great Singer when you first come out,the GP will always look at you in that light..that why Christina is looked at as the voice of the Gen.but Kelly and be could sing laps around Christina.she hit the same sh*t over & over.Christina has more overall power.but Beyonce as a vocalist puts Christina to shame.

And that is the bottomline

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by CosmicLover

The delusion. LOL @ prestigious vocalist awards. But has she gotten a 'voice of this generation award' or a specific award saying she's the 'People's Voice'? That's the real tea here. That is what we are discussing. You can sit there and talk about all the accolades Beyonce has but is she on the Times 100 influential people list with an article written by CELINE DION about how great she is or Rolling Stone's 100 greatest artists of all time?! Nope!

Beyonce's head voice is one of the worst I've heard. Christina could wipe the floor with Beyonce's weak head voice any day. We should try to see if Beyonce could even pull off a song like A Song For You. God knows imhow bad that could be with what she did to At Last.

M
Please stop acting like Celine is any good. She's only a bit smarter about vocals than Xtina is.

And no one but the other Xtina stans would agree with you that Xtina has a better headvoice than Bey.