Kelly is a better singer than X but her music is so generic and simple. X took so much more risks musically.

She's above my other fave now (who is a monster seller in the UK)

Who would have thought

This they drag her for her vioce but if their fav did half as good as any of her performances they would praising them forever

Someday I'm going to give my kid a version of that book that just has it removed entirely.

Which is why she's the more respected Artist of the two.

um isn't she the girl who leaked In My Arms???

The only girls Xtina sounds better than now are Taylor and Britney. And Xtina only sounds "good" in her mid register when larynx is where it's supposed to be and she doesn't have to scream and holler basic notes.

I mean P!nk > Belly.

Like she loses against pretty much anyone. She's the most successful from American Idol but that doesn't say much when all of the winners and other contestants are flops, and mostly Local.

At least KFCelly stans have that overrated 'Breakaway' to fall back on.


'ERMAGERD Breakaway is the best, no album can compare"

She may have taken risks but they sure as hell didn't pay off.

Oh I'm not sure if it was her but that's what I remember reading

dijn; are you sure it was? Maybe it was just a song or two. Although I seriously never realized most Kylie stans were so messy until recently those 45-year old gheys that have been following her every footstep since 1987 are a MESS. the thought of them protesting the release of 'red blooded woman' STILL makes me laugh.

Global iTunes Artist Ranking -

27 Christina Aguilera
58 Ke$ha
295 Kelly Clarkson

- http://kworb.net/itunes/extended.html

Kelly's even below trash in the pop world right now even with her releasing an album most recently from the 3. I bet RCA isn't happy.

I'm not even an Xtina stan like that (although I do like her) but this is the truth.

Xtina can still get her Collabs to the top of the charts, she hasn't always been local, her last official tour did better than any of Belly's.

Belly may have more success right now(no matter how marginal it may be) but in the grand scheme of things she doesn't matter as much as even P!nk who everyone counts out more often than nought.

The last album was a Christmas album. Do you see any Christmas lights out your window?

That thread is so sad

I mean Genie In A Bottle, B2B, being appreciated for her voice. What does Belly have other than a Discography full of Second Rate Avril/P!nk rehashes and leftovers that nobody within a 5 Mile radius of Popeyes would waste their money on?

Who compares Kfcelly to Pink? Lmao

Although i think Kelly has a bit more relevance in Asia than Pink (i think)

Which is why you and others were so SWIFT to compare said Christmas album to a Regular album release? Christmas albums do sell more so I would hope that her album could do 500K at the most during Holiday season.

Jelly has always been successful in the US which is why she has no huge international following.

When was Xtina's last tour? 2006? When was her last global hit, 2007?