Quote:
Originally posted by 400Lux
This is not about who is a pop girl and who isn't, and it's not about who has a top 10 or who doesn't. It means that for most people, Katy's main talent should be songwriting. Yet, she doesn't put a minimal effort into it. And the songs she tried to write by herself are a mess.
It also means that if she isn't good as a songwriter, we cannot for sure grasp her identity through her songs. And this is my answer to the OP. We don't know who Katy Perry is, because when we listen to her, we're actually mainly listening to other people's work.
|
well everyone who has worked on Prism praised her. You are just writing that because you don't like her music , which is fine but don't lie.
Cirkut : I know people sometimes think the artist didn’t have anything to do with the writing, but Katy’s a great songwriter; she’s very hands-on. She knows what she likes, what sounds she’s going for, and is deeply involved in the creation of her music.
and others said that she knows what she wants .
Why should we put someone in a box just so we can say - oh she is a grown woman who is not afraid to show her sexuality , or she wants to be an artist and she loves fashion , she is american sweetie pie from the south with pop ( but she thinks she is country ) sound .
It was an innocent question but I guess I should have prepared for a not so perfect storm