Has she?

Beyoncé has maintained cultural relevancy since 1997, so no.

No

No.

isn't it the other way round bey surpassed gaga with the superbowl last year.

No


All the cultural relevance Gaga had is gone.

Anyone who says yes is either lying or just delusional.

Beyonce is not even a factor in japan. Dont confuse cultural relevance with grammys and album sales

Gaga was only relevant for 4 years, lets not

Lol no. Beyonce still has a strong cultural relevance more than 10 years after going solo. Gaga's star power has faded only 4 years into her carecer. She was just a flash in the pan

Yes.

Gaga promotes in Japan, Bey doesn't. She also screwed up by releasing her album late there.

Seem's like that's what you're doing. Bey wins either way

She hasn't toured Japan in quite a while. If she promoted and showed them some love her situation there would change drastically.

How so? "BEYONCE" had a messy release and no promo there. If she promotes it, I'm sure it will get a boost.

She has had solid album sales compared to her peers in JPN.

Dangerously In Love - ~350,000
B'Day - 400,000
I Am... Sasha Fierce - 220,000



TWOTW - 200,000
Survivor - 400,000
Beyoncé Fulfilled - 750,000
#1s - 775,000

One could easily make the argument that Gaga isn't really a factor in the U.S.......

She was above Beyoncé in cultural relevance during The Fame / The Fame Monster / Born This Way. Not now, let alone OVERALL cultural relevance

Over all?
Yes