It's meant to be nasty but not 'nasty in the bedroom' type of nasty.
More like 'underground nasty'.

Slave was a sexy song, Dirrty was a nasty song.

It's true though, just imagine Dirrty with the Slave 4 U video?
No thanks, I'll pass,

Thank God that Xtina wasn't afraid to go all out with the concept.

Dirrty was more iconic in the UK than Slave was tbh. The music was like always on TV.

Agree, as was the video.

Dirrty (No Rap Version)

Lol I see the only ones hating on the legendary Slave. Including the op. If they like Dirrty so much more then why make a thread about it?

They must really hate Britney to go these lengths

The polls don't lie tho and slave always wins this poll.

Dirrty. Doesn't mean Slave isn't amazing.

the backfire to the op though....

Slave

Dirrty!!!

It was all over MTV back in the day.

Dirrty.

Dirrty. S4U didn't age well imo.

I love both so I can't pick.

I f*****g love both, but I prefer little bit Slave.

Both songs only flopped in the US. They were WW smashes.
Anyways, Slave.

really? lol how so?
i love both songs but i just prefer Dirrty
i never said anything bad about Slave to backfire on me

i feel as tho ur reaching really hard here & idk why

Slave 4 U > Dirrty in terms of quality.

In terms of impact, is it even a question? Slave (and the 2001 VMA performance of the song) are heavily referenced to this day. Where is Dirrty?

For real. It's just sad tbh

Anyway, I enjoy both and still listen to them after a decade. Who does this wins

Slave, but only by a bit.

Dirrty should of smashed harder than it did.

Slave.