Discussion: What did Gaga have that Katy didn't? - Page 3

Auris

STOP REPORTING THINGS THAT TALK ABOUT GAGA!!!!

I'm so tired of seeing people report things whenever they talk about Gaga in ANY negative way... Please stop and actually talk about it rather than getting pressed and trying to end any and all talk about your fave that isn't to your satisfaction. Also, I'm sick and tired of seeing people afraid to post their opinions because they're threatened with WPs.

Anyways, Gaga was relatable by everyone and had a better album that more people could appreciate than Katy's.

YonceIsFierce

Quote:

Originally posted by mariomania

Gaga is much much more talented.

In what ways love?

Auris

Quote:

Originally posted by Save-Me-Nialler

Maybe the fact that katy makes music for 5th graders and those kids eat up basic bops like roar, and all of the TD era like the candy i'm sure adults aren't saying they are fans of katy. kids find gaga wierd and so do adults katy is basically a sell out to the children demographic while gaga might not have the kids nor the adults but still won't sell out to 5th graders

Roar is #1 on Adult radio though for 14 weeks

Ben.M.

Quote:

Originally posted by Shady

Miley is hands down the most controversial artist since Gaga yet she's struggling to sell 2 millions albums. And Miley is a very talented girl!

It's two albums but most of the copies sold were packaged as one so...

@ everyone else, yes Katy is slaying Gaga right now but my question was why was Katy never able to peak like Gaga?
Also Gaga may be underperfoming but she's far from being over. Applause sold 4.7 millions WW so far and ARTPOP did okay.

and thats why WCS and WB done so well but its not working for her as well as it did for gaga... oh an gagas music was better. TD was a huge peak look at total record sales for the era

IDontThinkSo

Quote:

Originally posted by Colin

Gaga had the bigger peak while Katy had the staying power.
I'll let you decide which is better.

yes couldn't have said it any better : clap2:
as a katy fan, i'm glad with my fav current performance. i don't need huge peaks. i am glad with how katy is performing on the charts and how her album and singles are doing

Grown K

Quote:

Originally posted by AriNikoBradshaw

STOP REPORTING THINGS THAT TALK ABOUT GAGA!!!!

I'm so tired of seeing people report things whenever they talk about Gaga in ANY negative way... Please stop and actually talk about it rather than getting pressed and trying to end any and all talk about your fave that isn't to your satisfaction. Also, I'm sick and tired of seeing people afraid to post their opinions because they're threatened with WPs.

Anyways, Gaga was relatable by everyone and had a better album that more people could appreciate than Katy's.

Well, as much as I love this site, there's no democracy here.

Bruss

Quote:

Originally posted by AriNikoBradshaw

Roar is #1 on Adult radio though for 14 weeks

And it surprises me to be really honest but just because it's #1 does not mean adults like it idk how that stuff work but is that not charted with radio play? well the label pays for the stations to play the songs right?

Roberto

What did Gaga have that Katy didn't?
A good voice.

/endofthread.

Ben.M.

Quote:

Originally posted by Save-Me-Nialler

Maybe the fact that katy makes music for 5th graders and those kids eat up basic bops like roar, and all of the TD era like the candy i'm sure adults aren't saying they are fans of katy. kids find gaga wierd and so do adults katy is basically a sell out to the children demographic while gaga might not have the kids nor the adults but still won't sell out to 5th graders

omg the excuses people have to stoop to

Harrier

performing ability?
/thread

Ben.M.

Quote:

Originally posted by Roberto

What did Gaga have that Katy didn't?
A good voice.

/endofthread.

wrong. katy has a nice sounding voice go listen to her acoustics then say that

SHICD

talent.

Shady

Quote:

Originally posted by Ben.M.

and thats why WCS and WB done so well but its not working for her as well as it did for gaga... oh an gagas music was better. TD was a huge peak look at total record sales for the era

but neither of those singles are up to par with Katy's or Gaga's biggest, in fact they performed about the same as Applause WW and Applause "underperformed". I was shocked when I found that out tbh.
TD was huge, no one's denying that.

ChrisRTW

Quote:

Originally posted by Colin

Gaga had the bigger peak while Katy had the staying power.
I'll let you decide which is better.

!!
Longevity really matters and Katy proved that.
While Gaga is stalled at 1.6m ww,so answer this gaga stans
What did Katy have that Gaga didn't.

Bruss

Quote:

Originally posted by Ben.M.

omg the excuses people have to stoop to

And they are true too

i will admit the only songs i genuinely like and appreciate from katy are Dark Horse, Unconditionally, and Thinking of you But the others and her album tracks are just

Roberto

Quote:

Originally posted by AriNikoBradshaw

STOP REPORTING THINGS THAT TALK ABOUT GAGA!!!!

I'm so tired of seeing people report things whenever they talk about Gaga in ANY negative way... Please stop and actually talk about it rather than getting pressed and trying to end any and all talk about your fave that isn't to your satisfaction. Also, I'm sick and tired of seeing people afraid to post their opinions because they're threatened with WPs.

Anyways, Gaga was relatable by everyone and had a better album that more people could appreciate than Katy's.

Because Monsters are always attacked by the other fan-bases.

So, what did you expect it? I would have reported this thread, but somebody made it first.

And you know the rules, in ATRL you can't express your opinion about an artist in a negavite way because you get warned inmediately.

J a y

Gaga's outlandish fashion and the rumour that she had a penis, played a part.

BionicLotus

the right question : "What did Katy have that Gaga didn't? "

Roberto

Quote:

Originally posted by Ben.M.

wrong. katy has a nice sounding voice go listen to her acoustics then say that

C'mon, girl, even Britney can sing well in acoustic performances. And Katy is a pop singer that most of her songs are not acoustic or slow ballads and she can't perform them well.

Tom_Ford

Quote:

Originally posted by AriNikoBradshaw

STOP REPORTING THINGS THAT TALK ABOUT GAGA!!!!

I'm so tired of seeing people report things whenever they talk about Gaga in ANY negative way... Please stop and actually talk about it rather than getting pressed and trying to end any and all talk about your fave that isn't to your satisfaction. Also, I'm sick and tired of seeing people afraid to post their opinions because they're threatened with WPs.

Anyways, Gaga was relatable by everyone and had a better album that more people could appreciate than Katy's.

AMEN!!!!