Poll: Whitney, Mariah, Celine? Which could do Beyonce justice? - Page 3

Swim

Mariah, always.

Blue Ivy

Quote:

Originally posted by Tigre

Why is Blue Ivy bullying Eternium just because he stated the fact that all three are superior VOCALISTS?

Anyways...Mariah has the versatility to pull off Queen Bey

Lmfao @ you thinking a baby can bully anyone.

Lmfaoooo @ y'all not sticking to the topic, which isn't about who is the better vocalist.

And lastly, LMFAOOO @ Celine being a better vocalist than Beyoncé.

BabyJane

All, you all give Beyonce' way too much credit, she can sing yes but she is not on the level of those 3 vocally.

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by BabyJane

All, you all give Beyonce' way too much credit, she can sing yes but she is not on the level of those 3 vocally.

Celine seems like she's overrated a bit, in my opinion.

2AM

Quote:

Originally posted by BabyJane

All, you all give Beyonce' way too much credit, she can sing yes but she is not on the level of those 3 vocally.

Pretty much.
-
Mariah would probably do them most justice.

TheNotebook

Quote:

Originally posted by Blue Ivy

Whitney would have embarrassed Bey if she sung Love On 17 Grammys. (In her prime) and I stan for my MOTHA.

ya think? The things Whitney would have done to Love on top. Epic slayage.

Out of the 3 women, the only far superior vocalist was Whitney. She was more expressive as well.Ad-libs were off the charts. Most of Beyonce's classics are fast-tempo songs which Whitney would've made into her own classics, not a carbon copy of Beyonce's songs.

Dragonfury

I voted Nippy cause of the attitude.

Mariah at her peak was more of a well groomed and more of a professional type of singer. I can't see Mariah doing Crazy in Love or Single Ladies.

But when it comes to voice, she can do better and if she's gonna do justice shouldn't even be a question.

Ascension

Mariah and Whitney, absolutely. Celine -- no ma'am. I just cackled thinking about her tone and odd fluttery vibrato over something like Get Me Bodied or Diva.

Just NO. Not here for that.

But, prime Whitney doing Get Me Bodied, Love On Top, Deja Vu, Sweet Dreams or Start Over? Dear God, my soul would not be able to take. The belts.

I could really hear Mariah in my head slaughtering Schoolin' Life, Hello, Smash Into You and Halo. I can just hear some sick whistles in the ad libs. Yes lawd.

Now I'm pressed because I'll never hear any of these and I want to.

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by Ascension

Mariah and Whitney, absolutely. Celine -- no ma'am. I just cackled thinking about her tone and odd fluttery vibrato over something like Get Me Bodied or Diva.

Just NO. Not here for that.

But, prime Whitney doing Get Me Bodied, Love On Top, Deja Vu, Sweet Dreams or Start Over? Dear God, my soul would not be able to take. The belts.

I could really hear Mariah in my head slaughtering Schoolin' Life, Hello, Smash Into You and Halo. I can just hear some sick whistles in the ad libs. Yes lawd.

Now I'm pressed because I'll never hear any of these and I want to.

I know.

leemaj

I'm Canadian so I'll always support Celine!!

dreamloverfantasy

Quote:

Originally posted by Ascension

Mariah and Whitney, absolutely. Celine -- no ma'am. I just cackled thinking about her tone and odd fluttery vibrato over something like Get Me Bodied or Diva.

Just NO. Not here for that.

But, prime Whitney doing Get Me Bodied, Love On Top, Deja Vu, Sweet Dreams or Start Over? Dear God, my soul would not be able to take. The belts.

I could really hear Mariah in my head slaughtering Schoolin' Life, Hello, Smash Into You and Halo. I can just hear some sick whistles in the ad libs. Yes lawd.

Now I'm pressed because I'll never hear any of these and I want to.

You bitch now you've got me pressed as well

KillingYourCareer

All of them cover Beyoncé vocally tbh, but Mariah's vocals are pretty much the best.

dreamloverfantasy

Mariah had enough sass to pull off a more uptempo version of Irreplaceable/Best Thing I've Never Had.

She could do Beyoncé's ballads too. Listen, Halo, Dangerously In Love, Pretty Hurts, Broken Hearted Girl, The Closer I Get To You

Kiddo.

The attitude, tone & styling of Whitney songs like:

Queen Of The Night
I Wanna Dance With Somebody
I'm Every Woman
All The Man I Need
I'm Your Baby Tonight

all sound like songs Beyoncé has since recreated. Just imagine Whitney singing songs like:

Upgrade U
Suga Mama
Green Light
Speechless
Work It Out
I Care

besides, the average Bey song is filled with loud, gritty, grainy, resonated and soulful vocals from start to finish. Mariah has always been much softer than Whit. I do think Mariah would be better on Bey ballads, just not her powerhouse songs. Leave that for The Voice.