inspired by my previous I AM...Sasha Fierce vs. Good Girl Gone Bad hit thread (x)

• Both are Bey and Rih's fourth albums
• Both albums were commercial underperformances by both artists' standards (however both were praised highly by critics)
• Both albums featured Bey and Rih being more hands on/personal with their music

this thread is always done and 4 always wins

4 of course

4.

schoolin life > rated r

love on top > rated r and I love Rated R.

I think Rated R is a lot more inconsistent but it has higher highs, so probably that

I think both albums are great though

i think i like rated r better. the lyrics are better for most of it, and its more to my taste stylistically. i definitely listen to it a lot more. 1+1 and love on top are still amazing though.

I really enjoy both, but LOVE Rated R.

4.
Love On Top > Rihanna
Run The World choreo > Rihanna

I prefer 4..

Slaydown>>>>>

Rude Boy>>>>LOT

Cold Case Love >>>>> 4

However, 4 wins as a whole.

4

This will not end well

This thread again. Anyway Rated R is amazing, can't say the same about 4.

I love 4 but Rated R is my favourite album ever.