Mte.

The first half was not live ... She moved her mic away from her mouth and that's when I realized she actually lip synced ... Let alone that her vocals after Jay Z sound way different than prior to Jay Z's verse

Still love Bey and I don't mind her lip syncing from time to time, she is still the best vocalist of our gen.

But she still pre recorded them, It's her voice and not the studio one so ..

It is the audio, not the mic feed. There is no reason to tremble while singing pre-recorded vocals, there is no reason to hear reverbs during pre-recorded parts either. But whatever.

My guess is when she says "how the hell did this **** happen" is they turn off her mic feed and TV feed at the same time so they don't risk the line getting out. I dunno, just a guess. But she sang on key the whole time. It was great.

This. I mean it's so obvious. http://instagram.com/p/jp0GdZN4a5/

Yep

lol beyonce did not sing live at all until jay z came out

ikr?? The live part!