Poll: Better Songwriter: Beyonce v Katheryn - Page 5

jomarr

Quote:

Originally posted by KangBey

The one who sold 2.7 million albums in 6weeks, outselling Prism, Unapologetic, Bangers, Britney Jean and Artpop.

This is relevant to the question because?

Anyways, the one not in question, Katheryn

black-star1

Quote:

Originally posted by Samuel

It's a greatly written song lyrically, but its quality is beside the point. Beyonce could not write and compose a song, period.

Brown Eyes says hi

Letemtalk

If it was an option, I'd say someone like Sia who writes for both of them.

Samuel

Quote:

Originally posted by superben

OP should have compared songs that they have sole writing credits on instead of their biggest hits.

That's only possible for one of them.

Samuel

Quote:

Originally posted by black-star1

Brown Eyes says hi

Key word being compose, Beyonce has a credit with another guy who obviously wrote the music. She can't even play an instrument or write music, so she can't be a better songwriter. That's not to discredit her, it's just how it is.