I don't care for You'll See, I'll Remember, or DCFMA that much tbh, but many of her other ballads not in this rate are amazing.

Finally sent!

Madonna got seven 10s, Mariah got four, Janet got three & Whitney got one

I like Rain & Take A Bow, but these ones are so boring.

Also Celine's aren't that bad Was "I Drove All Night" not a top ten in the US? I think its like one of her biggest hits here in Canada.

Madonna got 17 10s and Janet got 6.
Mariah got one too!

They're fine (except for the Evita song) but Madonna really has better ones than these that's for sure

Céline surprised me as well, at least she wasn't boring like Mariah or Whitney (except for the Beauty mess, ew, that song was really meh)

Celine got nothing more than a 3 from me.

Celine actually got mostly higher scores than Whitney (but I'm Every Woman and I have nothing are better than all of hers).

I would have given more 10s if I knew how generous every one else was going to be.

Wow so many 10s! I gave one just Janet, her Nasty slayed my soul

Madonna got 8 and I was taming myself

I would be more generous with Madge

I've only finished Mariah's and she has one 10

Partway through Madonna (at the True Blue era) and she has one as well.

No 1s yet though!

I'm Every Woman is a 9, a point deducted for not being the Chaka Khan version

should've been more generous with janet,mariah and whitney. madonna is gonna win this rating i see.

Ideal top 10:

Borderline
Cherish
Deeper & Deeper
Secret
Frozen
Don't Tell Me
Control
Rhythm Nation
I Get Lonely
Can't Let Go

!!

Some of these people gave Madonna more 10s than I gave overall.

Take out Deeper & Deeper & Can't Let Go and this is pretty good.

Just finished Madonna's 80s material and its really a mixed bag. It has great songs (Borderline, Angel, La Isla Bonita, Keep it Together) but some not-so-great stuff too.