Taylor Swift wasn't even that great back then, she has certainly gotten better but at the time she was nothing compared to Amy. A pressed individual wrote this.

They are absolute garbage.

I sincerely hope they crash and burn becase all of their articles are a biased, convoluted catty mess.

Tacky and simple uncalled for, I am so glad the comments on Rolling Stone are going IN.

What the hell? Who wrote this nonsense?

I can't even...

this is actually DISGUSTING

**** YOU RS

LOL - it's Rolling Stone not The New York Times

Although this was a terrible article. They, for the most part, write terrific articles. And the whole article was a mess, not just the Amy part.

I think people here are just mad that they shade your fave. They shade everyone's fave, but they give credit where credit is due.

I feel sorry for Taylor tbh. She was no competition for Amy back then but she is very talented, Red was actually quite a good album. Not all the award shows are only for the most commercially successful because otherwise it would just be the most successful people winning and there would be no point. besides Amy was very successful back then.

Amy Wasn't famous for her Tattoo's, drug addiction, alcoholism ect. She was famous despite of those things. She was an icon who was loved and inspired by so many including some of the faves on here.

We can't know how her Career would have done because she died, she was going to do another album after all and she was off the drugs so she could have easily had a huge comeback album.

Rolling Stone continues to crap on their credibility! First they put the Boston Bomber on the cover and now they're insulting dead musicians. Low Class and Tacky!


BTW Everyone and their mother knows that Amy deserved that award. Back To Black is one of the best albums of this generation. A timeless piece of work!

This was a MESS.

They didn't lie but it was still very disrespectful towards Amy.

2007 was BTB era

You tried it

They're entirely different artists and both deserved it.

Taylor really hadn't shown her true potential back then though, this was long before she wrote her really great songs, whereas Amy was in her peak back then so I'm not surprised she won

This is unnecessary and tacky. I love Taylor but I think Amy deserved the Award more than her at the time. Back To Black>>>Taylor Swift (the album)

Disrespecting the dead is horrible.