richa70: 3.5/10
Well you placed some input into you stanning and very little into the actual entry...(I asked for song links...) At least you gave some reasons as to your selections
1. You just said it was a great song...
2.

3. boring?
4. I guess that's a better explanation
5.

true
6. C'mon what should she cover?
Starships: 8/10
You did pretty good stanning in the thread

Idk if you were letting the songs speak for themselves, well that's cool, but in the challenge itself it was asked to provide explanations. All you provided is a worldly summary as to you song choice as opposed to actually telling the judges why you chose the songs you selected.
1. I can only agree on the highest selling description (Bad Romance is her best as an artist/critically overall)
2. I love Schiesse, never as a single but it was a great album cut
3. Wow what a mess of a song

4. And why the Bad Romance shade? Oh I see why, eh
5.

Totally agree (Summer 2010 teas for me)
6. Lady Gaga could only ever want a song like Madonna's Like A Prayer
rl231: 6.1/10
I only saw you change your signature/avi. Also I wanted to see more specific details as to why you chose the songs you did. The entry had a lot of general terms
1. There is like 3 songs you could have chosen, I semi agree with the final result
2.

Oh good she wrote this song

3. She wrote this

She has grown, its pretty messy.
4. The correct choice

5. Vocally this seemed challenging at the time, but it is pretty
6. idk about the striping comment, but definitely she can rock some good empowerment anthem at this point
Jax: 8.7/10
You and Citrus I swear, your stanning power was incredible

I was definitely impressed at the stanning in this thread and even outside of the thread (your blogs). Excellent.
1. I guess its a matter of opinion as Rihanna has many many singles to chose from.
2. This song is an excellent choice
3. Oh I liked the track actually. The real reason didn't convince me to why its the worst track
4. So I see. This video is indeed very Rihanna!
5. For looking into Rihanna's later work, I wish there was more reason besides the Navy defying
A Girl Like Me Album and it being a bop. Rihanna has several bops which is why I was hoping for some depth in your explantion as to why this is the most underrated track.
6. Perfect reasoning.
e437: 7.2/10
You did the avi/signature changes, but your posts didn't really involve stanning I'd home to see from you. You had some depth to your explanations so its a little bit more okay.
1.

This before Crazy In Love or Single Ladies. Decent reasoning although I could see this applying to CIL and SL

2. Decent explanation. I can agree with this
3.

I love Kitty Kat (probably for the reasons you stated) lol.
4. I will agree with you. Excellent explanation!
5. Light reasoning.
6. It would be intresting to hear her sing this. Although I could see the Hive-Navy getting into arguements for ages if she covered this

It would sound good.
Nasiir15: 6.3/10
You did some decent stanning actually

I did feel as though i might of picked on you in my explanations below, its more explanation then your teammate Starships, but most of your explanations had very little reasoning as to why you picked the song
1. Good song choice, but what about ur opinion?
2. Same as #1
3. Its not catchy, in what respect?
4. The best explanation so far. "Anyone with a pair of eyes can see that this video is iconic. " YEAS!!!
5. But my question to your statement is why should it get recongintion?
6. Good reasoning for Britney's vocal range
Timber: 9/10
I want to say your stanning in the thread was minimal (not as bad as others, but very underwhelming). HOWEVER From reading the explanations thus far, you blew all of them out of the water. Finally some indepth perspective! You analyzed the pieces very well and you gave (minus #5). Great job.
1. Embrace its iconicness!
2. Wow I love that you have a personal connection to the song
3. So i see. Sounds as if you were annoyed

Wait

4. Excellent Reasoning. You said it all
5. I thought it was spelt "Rumour Has It"

Also why was it on the same level as the other 3 "21" singles?
6. YEASSSSS
Citrus: 9.5/10
I love the stanning you did in the thread, but your blog

. So I just went with your whole third person explnanation, but yoiu at least did go into detail (and pretty much showed your opinion in third person lol).
1. I see you went all third person on me. I guess. Great reasoning!
2. So I see. Its a great album track.
3. I can agree, her metaphors on this track are just too messy and just a NO (although its a bop if you ignore the lyrics

)
4. Oop at the Katy shade. Decent reasoning.
5. Good indepth thoughts and reasoning. One can only imagine what she was alluding to on this track specifically.
6. OMG, oh wait. Well anyway I thought U picked Dancing in the Dark, Either song would/sounds epic. Go tell the Animals she should cover Bruce Springsteen

Great explantion.
FunkyDinevo: 5.8/10
I will say firstly I saw your avi/signature changes, but the lack of overall stanning in the thread at least was disappointing. Your explanantions sure seem to show that you underlyingly stan tho. However after reading through your entry, I'm left sort of torn. Sounds like you love Believe & Heart of Stone. But that's about it
1. I love the personal connetion you have to it. You sound like the ultimate stan!
2.I wish you at least went through an album and picked a song you liked

Love the explanation but C'mon, not even going through Cher's new album?
3.

idk what to think
4. But Cher isn't in the video. (now starting to question your stanning)
5. Okay that's better. Sounds like you have true connections to the song
6. This would have been an intresting cover if she did this when she was just divorced from (if Sonny were alive) Sonny (and the song was released at the time).
CBXC: 7.4/10
The stanning you seemed to do was moderate. Moderate. As for the entries, I had mixed feelings. On the one hand you had solid choices in terms of what songs you chose, on the other hand you provided a more technical reasoning to chosing your entries as opposed to telling us what brought you to chose the song (with the exception of a few selections)
1. I like the explanation except I wish you had a personal touch added to the entry
2. Addicted is pretty in depth. There are better album tracks, but the selection is okay.
3. Einstein is so cute tho (plus I told Kelly I loved doing Math to this song

), its a bit clever. Whatever, good reasoning
4. I love the imagery/haunted theme to this song. Who cares about the song success, the video>>>
5. Pleasure listen? Explain:___
6. WHAT!!! You didn't chose a COUNTRY SONG!!! It would be intresting to hear how great her vocal range could be
CrazyCat: 8.3/10
Best Presentation! Also your stanning was excellent this round (within the thread of course)! Then in reading your entry, this had less of a personal touch to it. Scratch that, you had reasonings to the songs you chose, but you only chose them because they were "Fun, Crazy, Beautiful, Catchy, sexy, Glamorous". I'm just saying if you expanded on that I could give you an easy 10. Easily.
1. Fun, Crazy, Beautiful, and F**kin good. I can agree
2. It is a fabolous song that never made it to a single.
3. yeah this song is rather weak, its verses were

4. I agree, the fact its colorful (much like Nicki's personas are) I agree
5. idk if you picked this song because of you possibly knowing I absoultely love the song and I've exposed that in this thread a lot

Va Va Voom was ROBBED

6.

your explanation at the end lol
*Scores are comprised with your level of stanning (5 pts possible) and your entry
*I am rating the song selections on the following scale: YES, Yes, I guess, Eh, No
*Each rate begins with a disclaimer, outlining the possible legitimacy of my opinion. I can't know all of their work and can't make myself love/not love anyone. Everybody is going to have biases, I just want to make mine clear.
Starships: 4 (stanning) + 4 (choices) = 8
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. Yes ("Edge of Glory" is also acceptable)
2. Yes ("Hair" is my favorite but this is more acceptable)
3. I guess ("Jewels & Drugs" would have been my choice)
4. Yes (no side comment. just yes)
5. Eh (I don't care for this song at all, and you didn't convince me)
6. YES (the meltdowns. I could totally see her singing this too!)
rl231: 3 (stanning) + 4 (choices) = 7
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. Yes (the fact that it's her only #1 doesn't lie)
2. Eh (Not too special but not a bad choice)
3. YES (what is this reggae Miley?!)
4. Yes (I hate it but it's definitely her best)
5. I guess (something from Breakout would have been my choice)
6. YES (I can see it, I would love it)
Jax: 5 (stanning) + 3 (choices) = 8
Please take my judgings with a grain of salt, there may be some bias as I hate her
1. No (Your favorite does not mean her best)
2. Yes (Beautiful song, unexpected for Rih)
3. YES (this song is so disrespectful to anyone that supported Rihanna after Chris)
4. No (Your favorite does not mean her best -- We Found Love, anyone?)
5. I guess (I don't like Rihanna, so I don't follow her, so sure)
6. I guess (This song is not good, so I guess Rihanna could do a good cover)
e437: 3 (stanning) + 3.5 (choices) = 6.5
Please take my judgings with a grain of salt, there may be some bias as I love her
1. YES (currently obsessed with this song)
2. YES (everyone hates it but it's so amazing)
3. Yes (Why was this was a real song?)
4. I guess (It's beautiful but I would have picked something else)
5. I guess (Never heard it, so I guess it is underrated)
6. No (What? Beyonce needs big, powerful songs)
Nasiir15: 4 (stanning) + 3 (choices) = 7
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. I guess (I prefer others but this one is i.c.o.n.i.c.)
2. No (This song is not entertaining)
3. No (She has much worse on her first two albums)
4. YES (So entertaining)
5. YES (This song is so catchy, but nobody gives it any love)
6. Eh (I don't see it, but I can't picture her covering many songs)
Timber: 3 (stanning) + 4 (choices) = 7
My judgings are unbiased but not well informed, I apologize. I don't listen to her.
1. I guess (SFTTR or SLY would have been mine but RITD is amazing)
2. I guess (I can't compare since I don't listen to her albums but this one was good)
3. I guess (see above)
4. YES (such a beautiful video, really perfect)
5. Eh (I don't care for this song at all and she probably has more underrated)
6. YES (She was born to cover this song)
Citrus: 5 (stanning) + 4.5 (choices) = 9.5
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. YES (This is the perfect Ke$ha song, so catchy)
2. YES (The folk influence, so catchy and beautiful)
3. YES (This try hard mess "ooh I'm so trashy has"
4. YES (Her videography is poor but this video is so fun)
5. No (This song is lazy, it deserves the dust it is paid -- loved your reason though)
6. Yes (This is an arena song and she is an arena artist in spirit)
FunkyDinevo: 3 (stanning) + 4 (choices) = 7
My judgings are unbiased but not well informed, I apologize. I don't listen to her.
1. YES (one of the first auto tune songs, used for art, not to make up for lack of talent)
2. Yes (I have heard few Cher songs and this was one of the best)
3. I guess (yes, it's bad)
4. I guess (This is pure catering to gays, wooooow)
5. I guess (It is beautiful!)
6. Yes (I could totally see her covering it)
CBXC: 3 (stanning) + 4 (choices) = 7
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. Yes (MLWSWY would be my choice but this is stronger)
2. YES (Cupid got me into this one)
3. YES (I cannot stand this song)
4. I guess (haven't seen her videography, but this is great)
5. I guess (I didn't find it special but if you say so)
6. Yes (They're so similar, Kelly would slay)
CrazyCat: 4 (stanning) + 3 (choices) = 7
I feel that my judgings are strong and unbiased because I am familiar with her work but not a stan/hater
1. YES (This song is so good, I loved it before I was popular #hipster)
2. No (It's great but she has much stronger, even Whip It is better)
3. YES (WHY is this on PF:RR?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!)
4. No (Freedom, Your Love, even High School are all better)
5. Eh (The fact that it was a single shows that it was overrated)
6. I guess (She totally could pull it off)
B]richa[/B]: 2 (stanning) + 1 (choices) = 3
1. No (She has much more classic and stronger singles)
2. No (This song is very weak)
3. I guess (It's not great, not awful though)
4. Eh (it's entertaining at least, not very memorable)
5. No (It was a single at least, got a great mv and performance)
6. ?
richa007 -
1/10
Starships -
6/10
Best Single - You basically chose the most generic answer, disappointed
Best Album Track - Amazing choice, I definitely agree it's her best.
Worst Song - Well yeah it's not the best but there are certain BTW songs which are worse.
Best Video - Hmm not my personal fav but you could argue it works.
Most Underrated - Actually Monster is adored by her fans, I love that song.
Cover Song - It doesn't suit her at all, I think you only chose it 'cause it's Madonna.
rl231 -
8/10
Best Single - Generic answer, I find this song overrated as hell.
Best Album Track - I like it, good choice.
Worst Song - Yeah it's bad. Oh lord.
Best Video - Obvious choice but yeah it works.
Most Underrated - Kind of agree.
Cover Song - Interesting choice, I could see it working!
Jax -
9/10
Best Single - Great choice, you had it tough with so many big hits but I'm glad you didn't go for the obvious.
Best Album Track - Love it, this is something a Rihanna stan would pick.
Worst Song - This track is very polarizing, I happen to love it but I know a lot of fans don't.
Best Video - I don't see this as her best, I think it's kinda bad.
Most Underrated - Girl this was the song on my Myspace page for like 3 years

I'm done!
Cover Song - Great choice, I love that Britney song!
e437 -
7/10
Best Single - Hmm no ma'am!
Best Album Track - Good choice - one of the few tolerable songs on 4 I love it.
Worst Song - Damn you had so much choice for this one I feel bad, Kitty Kat is pretty bad though.
Best Video - It's okay but I wouldn't call it her best.
Most Underrated - Kind of, an okay cchoice tbh
Cover Song - kiiiii. Yes ma'am.
Nasiir15 -
5/10
Best Song - Predictable tbh.
Best Album Track - Ugh not this urban mess.
Worst Song - WB is bad but her worst? Idk about that.
Best Video - Agreed, it's iconic!
Underrated - hm I wouldn't call it underrated... it's a bop.
Cover - I can't picture it tbh..
Timber -
7/10
Best Single - Predictable..
Album Track - It's good, nice choice
Worst Song - Ugh she has worse though.
Best Video - Yeah her videos aren't much, i'll give you this

Underrated - .... nothing on 21 is underrated... you should have picked Cold Shoulder or something.
Cover Song - PERFECT.
Citrus -
7.5/10
Best Single - Meh, not her best
Album Track - Last GODbye

Worst Song - There are worse sis c'mon
Best Video - Sure, I have a soft spot for Blow.
Underrated - HELL YEAH. It's one of her best songs ever. I stan.
Cover Song - Interesting choice but I'm going with it!
FunkyDinevo -
4/10
Best Single - It's an iconic song and one of her best but **** you for picking her most popular song.
Best Album Track - If I Could Turn Back Time was a SINGLE not an album track. Bye.
Worst Song - GTFO this song is iconic and I can't at you just picking all her most famous ones.
Best Video - It gave me a kii but it's not her best, you'll get a point for the kii though.
Underrated - Good choice. I'm still mad you just picked her most popular songs. You've done her wrong.
Cover - Hmm not sure how it would suit Cher.. She's an icon she could make it work I guess. I love the song anyhow.
CBXC -
9.5/10
Best Single - YES. x1million.
Best Album Track - I see you picking my old username

Maybe >> Addicted but this comes 2nd.
Worst Song - kiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii I always call this her worst, are you stalking me.
Best Video - You could have put Because Of You here again but i'll take this too.
Underrated - She is the Queen of underrated, but I do love this song. Should have been a single from Breakaway instead of Walk Away.
Cover - Why would she cover something which was inspired by her?
CrazyCat -
7/10
Best Single - Of course! Love this song
Best Album Track - You should have put this on the underrated bit. I do love it though! Guilty pleasure!
Worst Song - Ugh kind of. It's a love/hate relationship, mostly hate though.
Best Video - Not too keen on this video but you don't have much to work with.
Underrated - Kind of the opposite, this song is overrated (still amazing though but it gets so much praise..)
Cover - Hell YES. I love Work It!