|
Discussion: When Cool Girls Take Over | COMPLETE
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,048
|
Quote:
Originally posted by August
|
#13.
"BLACK ROSES", Charli XCX
AVERAGE: 8.275
Highest: 10 (5: Eglé, Dragonfly, THERihFan, supaspaz, genetic fail)
Lowest: 5 (lovesong)
1: none
2: none
3: none
4: none
5: lovesong
6: Stevie (6.5), Ice Cream Skies
7: Sky Ferreira, adrianbeane (7.5), madonnas, Ewan Chaos, Sláy (7.5)
8: MP2K (8.5), superiore-93, Nat A (8.5)
9: Blueberry Mary, Penk, sticks (9.5), Luigi (9.5)
10: Eglé, Dragonfly, THERihFan, supaspaz, genetic fail
|
Nuclear Seasons • You (Ha Ha Ha) • Take My Hand
Stay Away • Set Me Free • Grins • So Far Away • Cloud Aura
What I Like • Black Roses • You're the One • How Can I
Lock You Up
#7 • 6/13 LEFT
|
I like "Black Roses" and probably cite it as the best non-single on the album (besides "So Far Away", the cheated Charli song of the rate!!!!!!). Pretty fair placing for it. Sky officially has HALF of the songs in the top twelve, let's see how many of those she can sneak into the top ten! |
|
Quoting this for the top of the page.
Two songs left until we have our top ten - any guesses? Will Solange or Icona Pop be eliminated completely before the top ten? The latter has made it quite a ways since it's massacre left them with a single song, we haven't seen them since #25.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2013
Posts: 13,978
|
We finally agree on a song.
And Black Roses and Nobody Asked Me are both amazing!
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2011
Posts: 6,130
|
at Boys, Heavy Metal Heart & Nobody Asked Me (If I Was Okay) getting punchEd ouT.
Like <<<<
Black Roses TRULY overstayed its welcome. Boys left too early. Take My Hand needs to GTFO now.
The 3 remaining Sky tracks BEST be in the top 10, even if I Blame Myself is a biT overrated.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,048
|
|
#12.
"LOVERS IN THE PARKING LOT", Solange
AVERAGE: 8.380952381
Highest: 10 (3: Blueberry Mary, lovesong, Luigi)
Lowest: 5 (Ewan Chaos)
1: none
2: none
3: none
4: none
5: superiore-93 (5.5), Ewan Chaos
6: genetic fail
7: none
8: Sky Ferreira, Stevie, Dragonfly, Penk (8.5), supaspaz (8.5), madonnas, Ewan Chaos, Sláy
9: MP2K (9.5), Ace Reject, Eglé, THERihFan, sticks (9.5), adrianbeane, Nat A (9.5)
10: Blueberry Mary, lovesong, Luigi
|
Losing You • Some Things Never Seem to ****ing Work
Locked in Closets • Lovers in Parking Lot • Don't Let Me Down
Looks Good with Trouble • Bad Girls (Verdine Version)
#2 • 1/7 LEFT
|
The ONLY way I'd be satisfied with this song's placement is if it was subtracted by 10.
I MEAN, WHAT KIND OF FLAWLESSNESS?!?!?!
Solange's vocals are heavenly, Dev Hynes' simplistic production is gorgeous (which is true to the entirety of True, heh), and the lyrics are quite heartbreaking. Let me not talk about the falsetto that could ruin careers (I'm a falsetto queen, I know.) |
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 9/2/2011
Posts: 21,728
|
NOT my #1 there really is too much Charli here.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2013
Posts: 13,978
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
You HaHaHa shouldn't be this high.
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 3/18/2009
Posts: 35,164
|
What. The. Hell?
Sky's best song didn't even make the top ten?!
I don't even understand how this is possible.
Let me weep for "Boys."
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2013
Posts: 13,978
|
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
You HaHaHa shouldn't be this high.
|
I think it's Charli's 2nd best song after Stay Away.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,048
|
I'm going to see to it that there are several people here for the final reveal of the rate. SO... feel free to tell me what time you'd be here for the next update being (sometime within this week!) so I can figure something out and we can all enjoy the eventual winner of the rate! Let's close up this update...
|
#11.
"TAKE MY HAND", Charli XCX
AVERAGE: 8.4
Highest: 10 (6: Sky Ferreira, superiore-93, Eglé, Dragonfly, THERihFan, supaspaz)
Lowest: 2 (lovesong)
1: none
2: lovesong
3: none
4: none
5: MP2K (5.5)
6: none
7: Luigi (7.5), Ice Cream Skies, Ewan Chaos, Sláy
8: Blueberry Mary, adrianbeane (8.5)
9: Stevie, Penk, sticks (9.5), madonnas, Nat A (9.5), genetic fail (9.5)
10: Sky Ferreira, superiore-93, Eglé, Dragonfly, THERihFan, supaspaz
|
Nuclear Seasons • You (Ha Ha Ha) • Take My Hand
Stay Away • Set Me Free • Grins • So Far Away • Cloud Aura
What I Like • Black Roses • You're the One • How Can I
Lock You Up
#6 • 5/13 LEFT
|
Charli takes the lead of most songs in the top ten with five (!!!) to Sky's 3 and Icona Pop/Solange's 1, and coincidentally, those are the five singles released from True Romance. Two of Sky's three songs are the only non-singles in the top ten. Interesting, huh?
I was always kind of annoyed by this song and don't get the seemingly universal appeal for it. It's not a bad song by any means, but certainly not of the same quality as the songs it just beat out ("Lovers...", "Nobody Asked Me"). I'm starting to think I just don't get Charli as much as you guys do. I really like the outro, though. |
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/18/2011
Posts: 5,396
|
LMAO ooooops @ Solange. I forgot I didn't like the song that much on 1st listen.
Black Roses was in too long imo. I like it, but it's not top 15 material. And I like Take My Hand as well, but it's fine to miss the top 10. Take My Hand I used to not care for either but it grew on me. I LOOOVE the outro a lot.
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
Can't believe this left! Boo.
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 3/18/2009
Posts: 35,164
|
Oh damn, my Charli 10's got punched OUT tonight! Still rooting for "What I Like," though.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,048
|
Icona Pop served justice tonight, and "I Love It" made the top ten, as many people hoped. How do we feel about the Charli 5-Sky 3-Solange/Icona Pop 1 each top ten?!
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,048
|
When Cool Girls Take Over: The Rate
DAY 4 UPDATE OVERVIEW
TRUE - 1/7 LEFT (2 eliminations)
Losing You • Some Things Never Seem to ****ing Work
Locked in Closets • Lovers in the Parking Lot • Don't Let Me Down
Looks Good with Trouble • Bad Girls (Verdine Edition)
This Is... Icona Pop - 1/11 LEFT (no eliminations)
I Love It (feat. Charli XCX) • All Night • We Got the World
Ready for the Weekend • Girlfriend • In the Stars • On a Roll
Just Another Night • Hold On • Light Me Up • Then We Kiss
True Romance - 5/13 LEFT (4 eliminations)
Nuclear Seasons • You (Ha Ha Ha) • Take My Hand
Stay Away • Set Me Free • Grins • So Far Away • Cloud Aura
What I Like • Black Roses • You're the One • How Can I
Lock You Up
Night Time, My Time - 3/12 LEFT (4 eliminations)
Boys • Ain't Your Right • 24 Hours • Nobody Asked Me
I Blame Myself • Omanko • You're Not the One
Heavy Metal Heart • Kristine • I Will • Love in Stereo
Night Time, My Time
The Results... So Far!
11. "Take My Hand", Charli XCX «
12. "Lovers in the Parking Lots", Solange «
13. "Black Roses", Charli XCX «
14. "Nobody Asked Me (If I Was Okay)", Sky Ferreira «
15. "Heavy Metal Heart", Sky Ferreira «
16. "Set Me Free (Feel My Pain)", Charli XCX «
17. "Boys", Sky Ferreira «
18. "Some Things Never Seem to ****ing Work", Solange «
19. "Grins", Charli XCX «
20. "I Will", Sky Ferreira «
21. "Locked in Closets", Solange «
22. "Bad Girls (Verdine Version)", Solange «
23. "Love in Stereo", Sky Ferreira «
24. "Lock You Up", Charli XCX «
25. "Then We KIss", Icona Pop «
26. "Don't Let Me Down", Solange «
27. "Ain't Your Right", Sky Ferreira «
28. "We Got the World", Icona Pop «
29. "Night Time, My Time", Sky Ferreira «
30. "Just Another Night", Icona Pop «
31/32. "Light Me Up", Icona Pop «
31/32. "All Night", Icona Pop «
33. "Looks Good with Trouble (feat. Kendrick Lamar)", Solange «
34. "On a Roll", Icona Pop «
35. "Kristine", Sky Ferreira «
36. "Ready for the Weekend", Icona Pop «
37. "In the Stars" Icona Pop «
38. "Omanko", Sky Ferreira «
39. "So Far Away", Charli XCX «
40. "Cloud Aura (feat. Brooke Candy)", Charli XCX «
41. "Hold On", Icona Pop «
42. "How Can I", Charli XCX «
43. "Girlfriend", Icona Pop «
Charli n' Friends' Top Ten!!!
"24 Hours", Sky Ferreira
"I Blame Myself", Sky Ferreira
"I Love It (feat. Charli XCX)", Icona Pop
"Losing You", Solange
"Nuclear Seasons", Charli XCX
"Stay Away", Charli XCX
"What I Like", Charli XCX
"You (Ha Ha Ha)", Charli XCX
"You're Not the One", Sky Ferreira
"You're the One", Charli XCX
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/21/2012
Posts: 55,134
|
Losing You slaying deserves number one it was literally one if the best of 2012
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 9/2/2011
Posts: 21,728
|
Not a bad top ten I'd say! I'm still very upset over Lovers in the Parking Lot though.
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/18/2011
Posts: 5,396
|
Charli n friends lmao. There's always one!
Ideal top 10:
1. What I Like
2. I Blame Myself
3. Losing You
4. I Love It
5. Nuclear Seasons
6. You're NOT the One
7. You're the One
8. You (Ha Ha Ha)
9. 24 Hours
10. Stay Away
1-5 are interchangeable honestly. Actually even 1-7 are interchangeable. This is a pretty good top 10.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 3,576
|
damn, my poor baby Sky. Her strongest songs are still alive though... really thought Boys woulda made top 10.
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 3/18/2009
Posts: 35,164
|
I'm shocked Charli is the one dominating the top ten after she had so many eliminations early on. I would have liked to see things a little more balanced, since all the girls had some excellent tracks.
|
|
|
|
|