Discussion: Will Katy outlast Rihanna? - Page 17

M i x

Quote:

Originally posted by TKO

Of course it has. We have two songs in the Top 10 right now, Dark Horse and Roar. Why should we be discussing Uncle?

Cause it was performed dozens of times yet flopped.
Can we talk about YDO, not being performed one single time and with basic video, having the same peak as Unconditionally?

DIAMONDZ

PIU would've have over 100M views if she released it on time.

Rider

Quote:

Originally posted by TKO

They are too busy buying...

9. Roar - Katy Perry

1. Eminem featuring RIHANNA - The Monster

DIAMONDZ

Quote:

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

1. Eminem featuring RIHANNA - The Monster

CLOCK HA

NewRihannaStan

Quote:

Originally posted by RightAsRain

ugh poor uncle perhaps it would have done better without all the 5384847362 performance that showcase how tone deaf and off-key Katy can be.

Lol

it is such a good song too

katyperryshore

Quote:

Originally posted by DIAMONDZ

mhmm check it out

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehcVomMexkY

Already have, looks like she wants to sell sex *sigh*

TKO

Rihanna and Katy are the queens. I don't know why the Navy trying to bring her down. Rih would be embarrased.

Dark Miracles

Quote:

Originally posted by HumanitySector

But Katy can't even pull off "Roar" live

Katy is very inconsistent just like Rihanna when singing live, but she still has more to offer. She's a songwriter who clearly is able to write well-received songs herself (Thinking Of You went platinum even though it didn't peak that high) and her songs are in demand with other artists as well (Kelly Clarkson, Britney Spears).

I'd also like to add that Katy Perry can sing very well when she's performing acoustically, her acoustic Roar performance at the Grammy nominations concert was quite good.

Fanik

Quote:

Originally posted by Kkamjong

This isn't even a discussion anymore, just pointless catting at each other.

Rihanna will most likely outlast Katy worldwide because she has greater appeal in that sense, but Katy will probably outlast her and be more well liked in North America.

Rihanna >> Europe

Katy >> Americas and Australia

I have no idea about the asian countries, but the fact of the matter is both of them have areas where they are stronger than the other.

Don't even try and bring up touring because Katy'd 2nd tour was held in the middle of her era and she was much bigger when the era ended as compared to when it started. Rihanna has had many eras but JUST broke the $100 million mark with her 5th tour. That's not something you should be trying to drag Katy with.

And her sound is switched up, BUT that is NOT her album. There is a reason why her albums stall at 3 million sales. They are full of filler and the only good songs are the 1-2 big singles they try and push.

And Katy said she lowered her ticket prices, but in reality they are still expensive so don't even try that.

And please, Rihanna fans stop embarrassing yourselves with this "Icon" award. It's the American Music Awards, something America hardly even cares about a few days after it aired. Stop embarrassing yourselves for acting like it's anything more than it is.

And please, neither Rihanna NOR Katy have outstanding vocals. Stop trying to use that

funny how her filler infested albums get more acclaim than katy's masterpieces

and dont forget the grammys

EthaneFenty

Quote:

Originally posted by NewRihannaStan

Lol

it is such a good song too

Atrocious vocals can really kill a good song

NewRihannaStan

PUI peaked without a video and promo...

RightAsRain

Quote:

Originally posted by DIAMONDZ

Quote:

Originally posted by NewRihannaStan

DH was performed .. But let's talk about Uncle how many performances did it have.????

idk but her vocals on that AMA's performance was a messT.

All the pretty stage just to distract from the awful singing

Fanik

Quote:

Originally posted by TKO

Rihanna and Katy are the queens. I don't know why the Navy trying to bring her down. Rih would be embarrased.

and the kats arent trying to bring rih down right

but I agree both are the biggest pop stars of their generation

NewRihannaStan

Quote:

Originally posted by TKO

Rihanna and Katy are the queens. I don't know why the Navy trying to bring her down. Rih would be embarrased.

Mess when we have 17 pages of you trying to drag Rihanna.. Don't play

Kkamjong

Quote:

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

1. Eminem featuring RIHANNA - The Monster

-

Samuel

I think Katy will "retire" quicker, she's older and in a committed relationship and I see her starting a family after a couple more albums. If hypothetically both of them continued recording for years to come I think it'd be pretty even.

Mess @ the Navy coming for Katy's vocals and level of "talent" tho. I mean I use Rih but let's not

Haunted.

legend R will destroy ha.

Fred Perry

Quote:

Originally posted by MadelineXPepito

None of them can properly sing or perform, but at least Rihanna doesn't use a safe formula and the same producer for 3 albums. People are constantly curious of what she'll do next, even though she releases every year.

So we are just going to forget about Stargate now? Last time I checked he produced a lot of singles on both GGGB, Rated R and Loud

TKO

Quote:

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

1. Eminem featuring RIHANNA - The Monster

Quote:

Originally posted by DIAMONDZ

CLOCK HA

Your point?

I love Rihanna. Where did i say that The Monster wasn't slaying?

NewRihannaStan

Katy doesn't have the uS when Taylor is too busy outselling her an P!nk owns Aussie