Replaying Silent Hill 2, still scares the **** out of me, especially alone at night with the lights off. Resident Evil remake is another amazing horror game. The only probleme with these games is having to get used to the tanky controls in the beginning
Out of the amount of games I've played only these have kind of scared me
Dead Island - When the zombies get up out of nowhere or when they appear between the rain
Riptide - Almost the same as Dead Island
Silent Hill 2/3 - Some scenes are creepy and it's worst when you're playing at night